---
title: The rural juror
author: Jean Booth
url: https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-august/the-rural-juror
---

# [The rural juror](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-august/the-rural-juror "The rural juror")

## How we built a jury research program instead of buying one

[Jordan Maurer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jordan-maurer "Jordan Maurer")

[2026 August](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-august)

**By Jordan Maurer **

For years, I assumed meaningful jury research was something only larger plaintiff firms could afford. Between jury consultants, professional recruiting, dedicated facilities, and production costs, it seemed like an investment reserved for catastrophic cases. As a young solo practitioner, I simply couldn’t justify that expense on many of my cases.

Then, in March 2020, everything changed. Like most lawyers, I found myself scrambling to build a remote practice almost overnight. Web cameras and microphones were nearly impossible to find. I bought whatever equipment I could get my hands on and slowly built a hybrid office capable of handling remote hearings, depositions, and client meetings. I didn’t realize it at the time, but I was also building most of the infrastructure I would eventually use to conduct focus groups in-house.

A few years later, I participated in a professionally run focus group on a case I was handling as co-counsel with a larger firm. It was incredibly well done, and incredibly expensive. I remember thinking that I would love to do something similar, but I couldn’t justify that kind of investment on a case worth $1 million or less.

That changed after I attended an elder abuse conference and learned about a plaintiff firm on California’s Central Coast that was conducting its own focus groups. If they could build that capability themselves, maybe I could, too.

I practice in Auburn, primarily in Placer and Nevada Counties. Compared to larger metropolitan areas, there simply are not many personal-injury jury trials here. I’ve had several cases settle on the courthouse steps after jurors were called in, but relatively few have gone to verdict. I hope to change that over the course of my career, but for now, fewer jury trials mean fewer opportunities to develop the instincts that come from regularly standing in front of local jurors. Ironically, that made jury research even more valuable.

Practicing in a rural community comes with unique advantages and challenges. We don’t have the trial volume of Los Angeles or Orange County, but we do have something equally valuable: relationships. We know our courthouse. We know our local vendors. We know our law library. And while we may think we know how people in our community view cases, experience has taught me not to make assumptions.

Rural juries are not nearly as predictable as many people assume. One panel may include lifelong ranching families, retirees who relocated from the Bay Area, teachers, healthcare workers, tradespeople, business owners, and young families who recently moved here seeking a different lifestyle. Some embrace the rapid growth of our communities while others resist it. Rather than assume we knew how local jurors would react, we decided to ask them.

**Using the County Law Library**

Our first focus group was simple. My office sits across the street from the Placer County Law Library, so we rented the library for the day. We posted an advertisement on Craigslist, bought lunch, handed out Visa gift cards, read everything we could find about running focus groups, and wrote our own script. We recorded the discussions with equipment we already owned. It wasn’t polished, but it worked. More importantly, we learned as much about running focus groups as we did about our case.

We’ve continued refining the process ever since. Today, we still use the law library. We get another local attorney to read the script to the mock jurors. We still recruit locally. The difference is that the system has become repeatable. We use technology we already own for our daily practice. AI helps us organize scripts and summarize feedback. Online survey tools allow us to collect responses in real time while paper surveys provide a backup. We record every discussion using multiple systems because we’ve learned that technology occasionally fails. The goal isn’t to build a Hollywood production studio. It’s to create a dependable process that gives us honest feedback from people who resemble the jurors we may eventually face.

Not every focus group needs to be a full-day production. On Saturdays, we typically run longer sessions covering liability, causation, and damages, often for less than $2,000. During the week, we may bring in six or eight participants for a couple of hours to test a single issue, refine voir dire questions, practice presenting a difficult piece of evidence, or simply get another set of eyes on a problem. Those shorter sessions often cost less than $1,000.

One unexpected benefit has been repetition. Every focus group improves the next one. We’ve definitely made mistakes. We’ve recruited too few participants and watched our numbers shrink because people failed to show up. We now overbook. We’ve accidentally saved recordings to the wrong Zoom account and learned the importance of redundant recording systems. We’ve handed out the wrong surveys and rewritten our checklists.

One Saturday morning, two participants arrived who had participated in one of our focus groups only a few months earlier. We recognized them immediately. We learned they applied for the focus group using different names than what they provided previously. It was certainly frustrating, but we explained that we couldn’t use repeat participants to evaluate the same kinds of issues, paid them anyway for making the trip, and thanked them for coming. It was a small expense, but it highlighted something we hadn’t anticipated: We had run enough focus groups that we now needed a more sophisticated participant database and better screening procedures. Like everything else, the system evolved because we kept using it.

**A rehearsal for trial**

The focus groups have also become valuable trial rehearsals. We set up the room using the same projectors, presentation boards, laptops, and technology we expect to use in trial. Our attorneys and staff become more comfortable organizing evidence, managing exhibits, and solving technical problems before they ever walk into a courtroom. In rural counties where jury trials are relatively infrequent, those repetitions matter.

Perhaps the biggest surprise is that we rarely leave focused on a verdict number. Instead, we leave with better questions. Jurors routinely identify facts they want to know, assumptions we didn’t anticipate, and issues we failed to explore during discovery. Those conversations influence depositions, expert preparation, mediation strategy, and trial themes. Sometimes they confirm our thinking. More often, they expose blind spots we didn’t know existed.

We still see tremendous value in experienced jury consultants, particularly in larger or more complex cases. But by conducting our own focus groups first, we become better prepared and, ultimately, better clients when we do seek outside assistance.

The real lesson wasn’t that we found a cheaper way to conduct focus groups. It was that we stopped viewing jury research as something we purchased and started viewing it as something we built. Every session improved our scripts, our presentation skills, our technology, and our understanding of how people in our own community think about the cases we bring.

That’s one of the unexpected advantages of practicing in a rural community. We may not have the biggest budgets or the highest volume of jury trials, but we do have the opportunity to experiment, refine our systems, and keep improving. Over time, those small improvements have transformed jury research from an occasional luxury into a regular part of how we prepare cases. And I believe it has made us better trial lawyers.

*Jordan Maurer is the founder of*Maurer Law*in Auburn, California. He represents individuals and families in personal injury and elder abuse cases throughout Northern California, primarily in the Gold Country and Lake Tahoe regions. His practice focuses on TBI and spine injury cases. After building his trial skills at leading plaintiff and defense firms in larger cities, Jordan returned home to serve the rural communities that shaped him.*

### [Jordan Maurer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jordan-maurer "Jordan Maurer")

[![Jordan Maurer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Maurer-Jordan_45746e0d784ae252b891e9ea8d2f7817.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jordan-maurer "Jordan Maurer")

Jordan Maurer is the founder of Maurer Law, a plaintiff firm based in Auburn, California, with offices throughout the Sierra foothills. His practice focuses on catastrophic injury, wrongful death, and elder abuse cases. He serves on the Executive Committee of the California Lawyers Association’s Law Practice Management and Technology Section and writes about trial practice, jury research, and building a sustainable plaintiff practice outside a major metro market.

### Subject Matter Index

[Juries and Jury Selection](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Juries%20and%20Jury%20Selection)
