---
title: Hidden Safety Standards
author: Lee Farmer
url: https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-may/hidden-safety-standards
---

# [Hidden Safety Standards](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-may/hidden-safety-standards "Hidden Safety Standards")

## Beyond OSHA: How lesser-known consensus standards influence injury litigation

[Bryan Netherland](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/bryan-netherland "Bryan Netherland")

[2026 May](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-may)

Attorneys evaluating workplace injury or premises liability cases tend to start with a familiar question: Did the responsible party violate an applicable regulation? In workplace injury cases, that often means looking at whether OSHA requirements were met. It is a reasonable starting point; however, in my experience working as an OSHA safety expert witness, regulatory compliance is rarely the full picture, and in some cases it is not even the most useful one.

Across industries, technical consensus standards developed by organizations such as the American National Standards Institute (ANSI), ASTM International, the International Organization for Standardization (ISO), and the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) establish detailed, field-tested guidance on safe practices. These standards are built by working committees of engineers, safety professionals, manufacturers, and regulators who have spent careers understanding how specific hazards develop and what it takes to prevent them. Their work often goes far deeper than any federal regulation.

Although these standards are widely described as voluntary, they carry real weight in formation of expert opinion. They help attorneys, courts, and juries understand what hazards were reasonably foreseeable and what the industry understood about preventing them long before an incident occurred. In fact, OSHA sometimes relies on consensus standards when evaluating recognized hazards and, in some cases, incorporates them directly into federal regulations by reference.

**What consensus standards actually do**

Consensus standards exist across virtually every technical field. They cover machine-guarding safety distances, pedestrian walkway design, slip-resistance thresholds, illumination levels for public spaces, emergency egress requirements, and hundreds of other safety-specific subjects. Unlike OSHA regulations, they are not automatically enforceable laws, but they represent the accumulated knowledge of an industry about how accidents happen and how they can be avoided, which is precisely why they matter in litigation.

OSHA regulations are intentionally broad. The agency must address an enormous range of industries and workplace conditions within a single regulatory framework, and many of its standards function as performance-based requirements. They tell employers to address recognized hazards without prescribing a single method for doing so. That flexibility is by design, but it also means gaps exist.

Consensus standards fill those gaps. They offer the technical specificity that OSHA often cannot provide. When a regulation is silent or ambiguous about a particular hazard, these standards can demonstrate what a reasonably prudent employer, contractor, or property owner should have known and what precautions experienced safety professionals considered standard practice.

**When regulations leave gaps: A practical example**

Walking-working surfaces offer a useful illustration. OSHA’s Walking-Working Surfaces Standard (29 CFR 1910 Subpart D) establishes mandatory requirements to prevent slips, trips, and falls. Employers must keep surfaces clean and free from hazards such as loose materials, spills, and structural defects. What OSHA does not do is prescribe specific technical thresholds for conditions like acceptable elevation changes or required slip-resistance values. That level of detail falls outside the scope of what a federal regulation typically provides.

ASTM F1637 addresses exactly that gap. This standard covers the safe design, construction, and maintenance of pedestrian walkways, including guidance on surface uniformity, drainage design, and acceptable slip resistance. In a slip, trip, or fall case, an expert evaluating the incident scene would not stop at asking whether the employer met OSHA’s general requirements. The more probing question is whether the condition of the walkway was consistent with the design and maintenance practices that ASTM F1637 describes.

In many cases, the central issue is not whether OSHA explicitly prohibited a particular condition. It is whether the hazard was reasonably foreseeable based on what the safety community broadly understood. Consensus standards provide the technical framework that helps answer that question, sometimes establishing expectations that go beyond what any regulation requires.

**Beyond the workplace**

Consensus standards are not limited to employer-employee relationships or traditional worksite environments. Many of them address hazards that arise in public spaces, including walkways, parking areas, building entrances, stairways, and common areas in commercial or residential properties.

ASTM F1637 is one example, but there are others. Illuminating Engineering Society (IES) standards establish recommended lighting levels for pedestrian areas to support visibility and reduce fall risk. NFPA publishes standards addressing emergency egress, stairway design, and life safety that apply to publicly accessible buildings, not just workplaces. In premises liability cases, where the analysis often hinges on whether a property owner should have anticipated a particular hazard, these standards can be essential in establishing what the industry understood about the risk and what precautions were commonly expected.

That is the practical value of these standards in litigation. They do not speak to isolated or fringe theories of hazard prevention. They reflect what experienced engineers and safety professionals, working collectively over years, determined to be accepted practice. Referencing them in expert analysis grounds the evaluation in that broader professional consensus.

**Why attorneys should look beyond regulatory compliance**

In my work as an expert witness, I frequently encounter cases where the regulatory analysis is clean. The employer met every applicable OSHA requirement, yet someone was seriously injured. That outcome should not be treated as a closed question. It could imply the investigation has not gone far enough to determine a root cause or system gap.

Consensus standards can identify the gap between minimum regulatory compliance and what experienced professionals recognized as necessary to adequately control a hazard. They do not automatically establish liability, and they do not replace regulatory requirements. But when examined alongside incident evidence, applicable regulations, and sound expert analysis, they often reveal what the safety community understood about a risk well before the injury occurred.

For attorneys evaluating complex injury cases, that context can make a significant difference. The question is not only whether the rules were followed. It is whether the hazard was reasonably foreseeable and whether the response to it reflected the knowledge and practice that the industry had developed over time. Consensus standards, though less familiar than OSHA regulations, often speak directly to both.

*Bryan Netherland, MBA, MS, CSP, CSHO, ARM, is an OSHA and workplace safety expert witness serving plaintiff and defense attorneys nationwide in workplace injury and premises liability matters. With more than 15 years of experience in hazard recognition, accident investigation, and regulatory compliance, he has led safety programs across manufacturing, logistics, and industrial operations including Fortune 10 companies. Bryan is the founder of Seek Safety Consulting and an adjunct professor of occupational safety at East Texas A&M University. He can be reached at [seeksafetyconsulting.com/osha-expert-witness](https://seeksafetyconsulting.com/osha-expert-witness)**. *

### [Bryan Netherland](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/bryan-netherland "Bryan Netherland")

[![Bryan Netherland](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Netherland-Bryan_2cec8d5dd7369663e2ddf7af373b2882.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/bryan-netherland "Bryan Netherland")

*Bryan Netherland, MBA, MS, CSP, CSHO, ARM, is an OSHA and workplace safety expert witness serving plaintiff and defense attorneys nationwide in workplace injury and premises liability matters. With more than 15 years of experience in hazard recognition, accident investigation, and regulatory compliance, he has led safety programs across manufacturing, logistics, and industrial operations including Fortune 10 companies. Bryan is the founder of Seek Safety Consulting and an adjunct professor of occupational safety at East Texas A&M University. He can be reached at [seeksafetyconsulting.com/osha-expert-witness](https://seeksafetyconsulting.com/osha-expert-witness)**. *

### Subject Matter Index

[Discovery (see also Depositions)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Discovery%20(see%20also%20Depositions))
