---
title: Fifty years after the diagnosis
author: Lee Farmer
url: https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-november/fifty-years-after-the-diagnosis
---

# [Fifty years after the diagnosis](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-november/fifty-years-after-the-diagnosis "Fifty years after the diagnosis")

## The Molien family, lest we forget

[Craig Wesley Rimer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/craig-wesley-rimer "Craig Wesley Rimer")

[Jeffrey Sevey](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jeffrey-sevey "Jeffrey Sevey")

[2026 November](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-november)

On December 8, 1976, a Kaiser physician informed Valerie Molien that she had syphilis. She did not, and neither did her husband. The error was soon apparent, but its consequences were not so easily corrected, and the family’s name would pass into California law as shorthand for a principle the Moliens themselves never lived to see vindicated in their own case. Fifty years have passed and their story deserves to be told.

**A family in Daly City**

Valerie Gloria Rivera was born on April 14, 1942 in Raton, New Mexico, one of eight children of Mariana and Federico “Fred” Rivera. Her father had emigrated from Zacatecas, Mexico, and labored in the coal mines of Dawson, New Mexico, where he met and married Mariana before embarking upon a long career with Phelps Dodge.

Stephen H. Molien was raised in Denver, Colorado, the son of a high school social studies teacher, and served in the United States Navy during the late 1950s. The couple married in Las Vegas on June 15, 1964 and established their home on Eastgate Drive in Daly City, a short walk from Thornton State Beach. Stephen was employed by the Daly City Water District and Valerie worked as a clerk. Their only child, Natalie Ann, was born on February 6, 1965. By every outward appearance, the Moliens enjoyed a stable marriage and the promise of a secure future.

**The diagnosis**

In late November 1976, Valerie underwent a routine physical examination at Kaiser Hospital. Several days later she was notified that a test result was abnormal and asked to see Dr. Thomas Kilbridge. On December 8, by her account, the doctor told her that she had syphilis, administered a double dose of penicillin, and directed that her husband be brought in for testing. Further testing showed that neither had the disease.

Dr. Kilbridge would maintain throughout the ensuing litigation that he had described the diagnosis only as “presumptive, tentative, or possible.” Valerie was equally adamant that he had expressed no such qualification. Whatever words were said that day, the implication of infidelity precipitated a marital crisis which the relationship would not survive.

By March 1977, Valerie had petitioned for dissolution in San Mateo County and moved with daughter Natalie into her sister’s home. Her declarations in that proceeding describe physical abuse, verbal attacks, and increasingly erratic conduct, including her husband’s conviction that he was “the son of God” and that his deceased father had taken up residence within him. The file further records a restraining order, a probation department investigation concerning visitation, and Stephen’s confinement for a time in a mental hospital. A final decree was entered in March 1978 and the marriage ended. Whether the diagnosis caused that collapse or merely struck a marriage and a mind already under strain, is a question no tribunal ever resolved.

**Fifteen years without resolution**

Stephen brought suit in July 1977. After the trial court sustained demurrers, the California Supreme Court reversed in 1980, and *Molien v. Kaiser Foundation Hospitals* took its place among the landmark decisions of California tort law. For the Moliens, however, the appeal marked not the end of the litigation, but merely the end of its beginning.

The matter returned to San Mateo County, where Kaiser contested the case vigorously, at one point attributing the breakdown of the marriage to the Moliens themselves. In 1983, according to the sworn declarations of Stephen’s counsel, the parties reached agreement on a settlement, but it required Dr. Kilbridge’s consent, and he declined. Three judges encouraged him to relent. Dr. Kilbridge, counsel wrote, “has continued to insist on trial.”

That trial never occurred. Successive trial dates were vacated for want of an available judge or the absence of an expert witness. In 1986 the parties agreed to submit the dispute to arbitration, yet the hearing did not commence until February 1992. Three days later, a majority of the panel found in favor of Kaiser. When Kaiser petitioned to confirm the award, no one appeared in opposition. Nearly 15 years after the litigation began, neither Stephen nor Valerie had recovered anything.

**The aftermath**

Valerie later married local teacher Joseph Sheehan and was employed for many years as a secretary with PG&E. She died of cancer in 2002 at the age of 59. Stephen never remarried. Alcoholism killed him in 2003; he spent the final years of his life in a San Francisco homeless shelter. Natalie continues to reside in the area. Dr. Kilbridge, long retired, lives on the Peninsula; no court or arbitrator ever found that he was negligent.

The result leaves an enduring paradox. The Moliens gave their name to a court case that opened the way to plaintiffs whose injuries were real, though unaccompanied by physical harm, and every California practitioner who has since pleaded such a claim stands in their debt. Yet the family whose misfortune brought that change about recovered nothing at all.

*Craig Wesley Rimer JD CLI, a Certified Legal Investigator licensed since 1981, practices civil trial support in personal injury, business, real estate, and wills, trusts, and estates matters.*

*Jeffrey C. Sevey, AV-rated California attorney admitted to the State Bar in 1992, specializes in personal-injury and wrongful-death litigation. *

### [Craig Wesley Rimer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/craig-wesley-rimer "Craig Wesley Rimer")

[![Craig Wesley Rimer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Rimer_2c23dc380435a9ca16d216e1ad9a3791.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/craig-wesley-rimer "Craig Wesley Rimer")

*Craig Wesley Rimer JD CLI, a Certified Legal Investigator licensed since 1981, practices civil trial support in personal injury, business, real estate, and wills, trusts, and estates
matters.*

### [Jeffrey Sevey](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jeffrey-sevey "Jeffrey Sevey")

[![Jeffrey Sevey](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Sevey_cc07931074dbac81652dffd893118fbe.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/jeffrey-sevey "Jeffrey Sevey")

*Jeffrey C. Sevey, AV-rated California attorney admitted to the State Bar in 1992, specializes in personal-injury and wrongful-death litigation. *

![Fifty years after the diagnosis](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/image001_bef5ffdbdcb53531171567753e19c5f8.png)

Valerie Gloria Rivera

![Fifty years after the diagnosis](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/image002_5ec8d21d29e56ddb1b150c78fe1e99e3.png)

Dr. Thomas Kilbridge

### Subject Matter Index

[Client Management & Expectations](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Client%20Management?Expectations=), [Law Office Management and Technology](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Law%20Office%20Management%20and%20Technology)
