---
title: How to read an ophthalmology operative note from cataract surgery
author: Lee Farmer
url: https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september/how-to-read-an-ophthalmology-operative-note-from-cataract-surgery
---

# [How to read an ophthalmology operative note from cataract surgery](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september/how-to-read-an-ophthalmology-operative-note-from-cataract-surgery "How to read an ophthalmology operative note from cataract surgery")

## The operative report is the surgeon’s account of what he did. It is not a complete record of the operation

[Marc Shomer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/marc-shomer "Marc Shomer")

[2026 September](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september)

Attorneys tell me the operative report is the hardest document in an eye case. Cataract surgery and most anterior segment operations follow a fixed sequence of steps. The dictation follows that sequence too, sentence by sentence, in the same order almost every time. Learn the template and you can see two things quickly: where the surgeon departed from it, and where something that should be there is not.

What follows is the document from header to signature. I will flag the phrases that mark a complication. I will also say, more than once, that those phrases usually record competent management rather than error, because that is the thing counsel mistakes most often.

**What the operative report is, and what it is not**

The operative report is the surgeon’s account of what he did. It is not a complete record of the operation.

Four other documents capture facts the dictation leaves out: the anesthesia record, the nurse’s intraoperative record, the implant log, and the recovery notes. Almost all of the analytic value comes from reading those four against the surgeon’s account and against one another, asking the same dull questions each time, which is whether the times agree, whether the laterality agrees, whether the implant described is the implant logged, and whether the events one document records appear anywhere in the others. 

**The header block**

Identifiers come first. Patient and record number, date and facility, surgeon and assistant. Then laterality, abbreviated OD for the right eye, OS for the left, OU for both.

That abbreviation deserves a minute of your time. Check it against the consent, the preoperative history and physical, the biometry worksheet, the nursing time-out, and the postoperative orders. Wrong-site eye surgery is genuinely rare. A clerical OD/OS slip in one document out of six is not, and a party will sometimes hold that slip up as evidence of a chaotic operating room. Work out early which one you have.

**The two diagnosis lines**

Every note carries a preoperative and a postoperative diagnosis. The gap between them tells you something. The preoperative line states what the surgeon expected to find. The postoperative line states what they found. When they match, the operation went as planned. When the second line adds something, a posterior capsule rupture, say, or a zonular dehiscence, the case turned.

Many surgeons simply dictate “same.” If the narrative below describes a complication while that line reads “same,” it is almost always dictation habit rather than concealment. It is also the first inconsistency opposing counsel will put to your expert, so be ready for it.

**Procedure name and anesthesia**

Routine modern cataract surgery is dictated as phacoemulsification with intraocular lens implantation. The cloudy lens is broken up with ultrasound and aspirated through a small incision, and an artificial intraocular lens, an IOL, goes into the capsular bag that held the natural lens.

Watch what is appended to that line. Anterior vitrectomy. Iris hooks or a pupil expansion device. A capsular tension ring. Sutured closure. Each of those tells you the case was not routine.

The anesthesia line separates topical drops from a regional block, meaning a retrobulbar or peribulbar injection, from general anesthesia. It cuts both ways. Blocks carry recognized risks of their own, including globe perforation and optic nerve injury. 

**The standard sequence**

Because cataract surgery is standardized, so is the narrative. Read for these, in this order:

Preparation and draping, with a time-out confirming patient, procedure and eye.

The incision. A small clear corneal or scleral tunnel incision, plus side-port entries called paracenteses.

Viscoelastic instillation. A gel that holds the space open and protects the inner surface of the cornea.

Capsulorhexis. A circular opening torn in the front of the lens capsule. Words like continuous, curvilinear and well-centered are the surgeon asserting that this step went as planned, and much of what follows depends on it.

Hydrodissection. Fluid injected to free the lens so it will rotate.

Phacoemulsification. Breaking up and removing the nucleus, often with the technique named.

Cortical cleanup. Aspirating the lens material left behind.

IOL insertion, with the final position stated. In the bag. In the sulcus, meaning in front of the capsule. Sutured. Fixated to iris or sclera. Position is one of the highest-yield facts in the entire document.

Viscoelastic removal and wound closure, with confirmation that the incision is watertight.

This is what a completely routine case looks like in full.

Sample OP – Report

**cataract extraction/ IOL right eye**

**DATE OF SURGERY: **

**IMPLANT USED: **

**PREOP DIAGNOSIS**: Age related nuclear cataract of the X eye.

**POSTOP DIAGNOSIS:** Age related nuclear cataract of the X eye.

**NAME OF OPERATION:** Cataract extraction with implantation of intraocular lens for the X eye.

**SURGEON**: 

**ASSISTANT:** None. 

**COMPLICATIONS**: None.

**ESTIMATED BLOOD LOSS**: None.

**SPECIMENS SENT**: None.

**ANESTHESIA**: Monitored anesthesia care. 

**INDICATION FOR SURGERY**: Visually significant cataract. The risks, benefits and alternatives of the proposed procedure were reviewed at length with the patient. The patient expressed understanding and wished to proceed.

**PROCEDURE**: After informed consent was obtained, the patient was escorted to the preoperative area. Tetracaine 0.5% was placed on the eye preoperatively. Preoperative tropicamide was used for dilation of the operative eye. The patient was then escorted to the operating suite and placed in the supine position. The patient was then prepped and draped in the usual sterile manner for ophthalmic surgery. 

An eyelid speculum was used to separate the eyelids of the operative eye. 

A 15-degree blade was used to create a limbal paracentesis port through which preservative-free lidocaine 1% and epinephrine 1:3000 was injected. The anterior chamber was then filled with viscoelastic. 

A keratome was then used to create a self-sealing clear corneal incision into the temporal clear cornea at the limbus. 

A cystotome needle was used to create a small tear in the anterior lens capsule. Utrata forceps were then used to create a continuous curvilinear capsulorrhexis into the anterior lens capsule. 

Balanced salt solution on a blunt cannula was then used to hydrodissect and hydrodelineate the lens nucleus which was then removed using phacoemulsification. 

Remaining cortex was removed using irrigation and aspiration. The capsular bag was then inflated with viscoelastic, inspected and found to be intact. The intraocular lens implant was carefully inspected manually prior to insertion into the eye. The intraocular lens was placed within the lens capsule without difficulty. The optic was well-centered and both haptics were within the lens capsule. 

Remaining viscoelastic was then removed using irrigation and aspiration. The intraocular lens was gently moved about in order to permit complete aspiration of all viscoelastic. 

Balanced salt solution was then used to hydrate the corneal stroma adjacent to the main incision site. The wounds were checked and found to be completely watertight and well-approximated. 

The anterior chamber fluid was released from the side-port incision so the intraocular pressure was physiological. 

The eyelid speculum was removed, the patient’s face was cleaned gently without disturbing the eye, and sterile dressings consisting of antibiotic ointment, a patch, and a shield were placed over the operating eye. The patient was then safely escorted to the recovery area by the surgeon and was found to have tolerated the procedure extremely well without complication. The patient was given detailed post-op instruction and our number to call should there be any questions. The patient also has a follow-up appointment in our office the next day. 

***Nothing remarkable***

Nothing in that sample report is remarkable, which is exactly the point.

**The implant trail**

Every implanted device leaves a paper trail, and this one is unusually good.

The note should name the IOL by manufacturer, model and power in diopters, often with a serial or lot number. The same data should appear on the implant sticker in the nursing record and again in the facility’s implant log.

When the dispute is about refractive outcome, this is where I start. Compare the power actually implanted against the biometry worksheet and against what the surgeon selected. That single comparison will usually sort the case into one of four boxes, and they are very different boxes: a measurement problem, a problem with the lens selection or the formula used to make it, the wrong lens in the eye, or a result that while disappointing to the patient still sits comfortably inside the recognized range of outcomes.

If the note omits the lens details, do not read anything into it. The data almost always live in the nursing record. What matters is that the packet establishes which lens went into which eye.

**The closing line**

Most notes end the same way. Estimated blood loss minimal. No complications. Patient tolerated the procedure well and was transferred to recovery in stable condition.

During intraocular surgery, blood loss is usually trivial, so that entry is boilerplate. So, frequently, is “no complications.” It is a template element, and its presence does not establish that the case was uneventful.

But put that line next to a narrative describing vitreous loss and you have a contradiction inside a single document. That one becomes a deposition exhibit.

**The phrases that signal a complication**

Certain language marks a departure from the routine sequence.

**“Posterior capsule rent noted,” or “capsular tear.”** The thin membrane behind the lens was breached. This is a recognized complication of properly performed surgery, and it is more likely in dense cataracts, small pupils, and eyes that have had a prior vitrectomy.

**“Vitreous presented,” or “vitreous prolapse.”** Generally, when vitreous is removed during a cataract surgery it is a complication, but not necessarily malpractice. A report might describe: “The gel that fills the back of the eye came forward through that breach.” Notice that the vocabulary is observational. It describes a finding, not a mistake.

**“Anterior vitrectomy performed.”** The prolapsed vitreous was removed with a cutting instrument. This is the correct response when vitreous presents, and its documentation is affirmative evidence that the surgeon recognized the problem and dealt with it. Again, this is a complication, but not necessarily a break from the standard of care. 

**“Zonular dialysis,” or “zonular weakness.”** The fibers that suspend the lens capsule were deficient, often from old trauma or from pseudoexfoliation. At times, the zonular weakness may be the result of the surgery. 

**“Lens fragment descended posteriorly,” or “dropped nucleus.”** Lens material fell back into the vitreous cavity. This usually prompts a referral to a vitreoretinal surgeon. This is a complication because the patient has consented to cataract removal and not all the cataract was removed. But again, this may not be malpractice if the lens moves into the vitreous. It is generally considered deviation from standard of care if an anterior segment surgeon (a cataract surgeon) chases the fragment into the vitreous, which can cause retinal damage. 

**“IOL placed in the sulcus.”** The lens is sitting in front of the capsule rather than inside it, a standard adaptation when the bag will not hold it safely. This is not the typical way a lens implant is generally placed, but it can be the only viable and safe option for some patients. 

**“Pupil expansion device placed,” or “iris hooks.”** The pupil would not dilate enough. This is a recognized situation, and it is associated with certain systemic medications such as taking tamsulosin or Flomax medications. This is classically used for prostate disease but there are other indications for these medications. Using these pupil expansion devices is the result of the inherent biology of each patient, however, not using it when needed is a deviation from standard of care. 

**“Wound sutured.”** The incision did not seal on its own, and the surgeon chose security over speed. This is less common, but overall a safety measure to ensure a well-sealed wound. 

**The point counsel gets confused **

Those phrases record that something difficult happened. Standing alone, they do not record that anyone did anything wrong.

Recognized complications occur in technically flawless operations. They always have. And when one appears in a note written by the surgeon who managed it, that is usually a mark of candid documentation rather than an admission.

The medical-legal questions are separate, and they come in order. Was the complication caused by a departure from the standard of care? Was it recognized promptly? Was it managed appropriately? Was the patient properly informed, and properly followed afterward?

A case can fail on any one of those questions while the operative note is full of alarming vocabulary, and a case can succeed where the note reads perfectly clean from the first line to the last, which is why the vocabulary is a starting point for the inquiry rather than the answer to it.

Here is a list of the most common intra-operative complications during cataract surgery and what the operative report might say. 

**What a missing element or “gap” means**

Notes are dictated from templates, or assembled by record macros, and elements drop out for dull reasons: The template lacked a field. The dictation was interrupted. The surgeon’s habitual phrasing leaves out a step he treats as implicit.

A note that does not mention hydrodissection did not necessarily skip hydrodissection.

A note silent on IOL position is incomplete, and that is a documentation problem rather than proof of a malpositioned lens. Position can nearly always be established from the first postoperative visit, anyway.

What a gap actually means is that a fact is unproven from that document. It moves the question to the nursing record, the recovery note, or the surgeon’s deposition. It is a reason to look further. It is not a finding. Usually, in a cataract surgery room, the only other person who might have a good idea of what is actually happening inside the eye is the scrub tech. They have a bird’s-eye view of the patient, but they may or may not be seeing what is going on inside the eye. 

The opposite error is just as common, and I see it from both sides: misreading unusually thorough documentation as defensiveness. Some surgeons simply dictate that way, and always have.

**Signature, timing and addenda**

The note ends with a signature or an electronic attestation, and the metadata around it repays a look.

Facilities generally require a brief handwritten or templated operative note immediately after the case, with the full dictated report completed shortly afterward, so same-day or next-day dictation is entirely ordinary and says nothing at all about the surgeon’s state of mind. Authentication timestamps are not the same thing as dictation timestamps, and a signature dated several days later often means nothing more than that the surgeon cleared a queue on Friday afternoon.

Addenda deserve the same restraint. A supplemental note that fixes a transcription error or adds an implant serial number is routine, and every record system permits dated, attributed amendment.

Three questions matter. What did the addendum change? When was it created, relative to the claim? And does it conflict with contemporaneous documents written by other people?

An addendum consistent with the nursing record and the first postoperative visit is corroboration. One that appears after a demand letter and contradicts the recovery note is something else entirely. Telling them apart takes the full packet and the system’s audit metadata, which is one more reason to request complete records rather than the operative report by itself.

**One last thing**

If you take nothing else from this, take the sequence. Read the note for the template first and the vocabulary second. Establish what the standard nine steps are, find where this operation left them, and only then ask what the departure means.

The vocabulary is frightening. The sequence is what tells you whether there is a case.

*Marc H. Shomer, MD, PhD, QME, is a board-certified ophthalmologist in Upland and an active California Qualified Medical Evaluator. He earned his MD and PhD through the UCLA Medical Scientist Training Program and completed his ophthalmology residency at the Jules Stein Eye Institute at UCLA. He has served as Adjunct Associate Professor of Ophthalmology at the Keck School of Medicine of USC since 2009. He has worked as an ophthalmology expert witness since 2012, in both plaintiff and defense matters. www.legaleyeexpert.com*

### [Marc Shomer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/marc-shomer "Marc Shomer")

[![Marc Shomer](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Shomer-Marc_67df5a7553a99f132331610efab9d1a7.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/marc-shomer "Marc Shomer")

*Marc H. Shomer, MD, PhD, QME, is a board-certified ophthalmologist in Upland and an active California Qualified Medical Evaluator. He earned his MD and PhD through the UCLA Medical Scientist Training Program and completed his ophthalmology residency at the Jules Stein Eye Institute at UCLA. He has served as Adjunct Associate Professor of Ophthalmology at the Keck School of Medicine of USC since 2009. He has worked as an ophthalmology expert witness since 2012, in both plaintiff and defense matters. www.legaleyeexpert.com*

![How to read an ophthalmology operative note from cataract surgery](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Shomer_-_Table_c6611fad7ecc0576e2db8c16637918e5.jpg)

The most intra-operative complications during cataract surgery and what the operative report might say.

### Subject Matter Index

[Client Management & Expectations](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Client%20Management?Expectations=), [Law Office Management and Technology](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Law%20Office%20Management%20and%20Technology)
