---
title: Mediation best practices in workers’ compensation practices
author: Lee Farmer
url: https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september/mediation-best-practices-in-workers-compensation-practices
---

# [Mediation best practices in workers’ compensation practices](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september/mediation-best-practices-in-workers-compensation-practices "Mediation best practices in workers’ compensation practices")

## Mediation can be a way forward for cases stuck in the WCAB backlog. For success, treat the mediation like a trial without witnesses

[Taylor E. Arnold](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/taylor-e-arnold "Taylor E. Arnold")

[2026 September](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/issues/2026-september)

Unlike many practice areas where mediation is either a requirement or a common step in the process, in California workers’ compensation claims it is seldomly utilized and rarely a requirement. Mediation is only referenced twice in the relevant statutes and regulations. The first, and most common, is in the context of Alternative Dispute Resolution “carve-out” programs governed by Labor Code sections 3201.5 – 3201.7. The other is in an obscure subsection of regulation section 9928, which gives the local WCAB information and assistance officer the authority to conduct mediation between the parties and issue recommendations in the event it fails. Many practitioners go their entire career without ever having to participate in the process; however, it is becoming increasingly common at the appellate level as a suggested offramp from the lengthy delays on decisions.

By the late 2010s the time between filing an appeal of a final decision or award of benefits, called a petition for reconsideration in workers’ compensation, and the receipt of the WCAB’s decision ballooned well past the 60 days allowed by Labor Code section 5909. This regularly resulted in delays of a year or more. In an effort to retain jurisdiction and deal with the backlog, the WCAB would routinely “grant a case for study” as a way to get around the 60-day statutory response requirement. In 2023, this practice was severely narrowed by the Second Appellate District in the case of *Earley v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd.*(2023) 94 Cal.App.5th 1, resulting in some changes by the WCAB, as well as increased resources being provided to address the backlog and ameliorate the problem going forward. Presently pending before the California Supreme Court is the recently argued case of *Mayor v. Workers’ Comp. Appeals Bd.*(2024) 104 Cal.App.5th 1297, which will have a direct impact on the time for decision of these appeals. As the uncertainty looms regarding whether the WCAB has retained jurisdiction on the cases that were previously “granted for study,” the WCAB has taken to the practice of recommending voluntary mediation to parties whose appeals are stuck in the backlog. In light of these recent developments, a brief guide to mediation best practices is in order.

At the outset, while mediation will not result in a dispositive decision on the merits, it should nevertheless be treated like a trial without witnesses. Although not required for workers’ compensation trials, an attorney preparing for mediation should prepare a brief addressing the strengths of their position and the weaknesses of the opposing party. The parties should ensure that the mediator agreed to has an understanding of workers’ compensation law, so the brief need not be a treatise addressing every factual and legal issue at play. However, even if the issue for trial was primarily a legal disagreement, the end result is almost always monetary, so the brief should include a succinct yet comprehensive analysis of the factual and legal support underpinning the offer or demand. An offer or demand should never be so high or low that it lacks any credibility, and there must be room to negotiate for the mediation to succeed.

It is key that you prepare your client for the legal and financial issues to be discussed as well as the process and strategy for negotiating a settlement. In a perfect world, this starts at your first meeting and is continuously addressed during the pendency of the claim, but the last thing you want is your client hearing for the first time from a mediator why they may lose their case, or why their demand is unsupported. The client should also be prepared to sit through the legal equivalent of buying a car, however they should view the mediator selling the idea of settlement in general, rather than trying to extract as much as possible for the opposing party. This is best accomplished by ensuring the client understands the mediator’s role, which is to settle cases, not represent the other party’s interests or make final determinations. A client who is placed on their heels by new information, or one who feels that the mediator is against them, will have difficulty trusting the mediation process, minimizing its chances for success.

As a final point, it is imperative that all parties with a stake in settlement be available during the mediation. If a claim is into excess insurance, or requires approval from higher ups, they should absolutely be a party to the mediation. If a claimant has liens that will need to be accounted for in settlement, such as a disability policy, those parties should also be available, if for no other reason than to have the mediator attempt to lower their demands as well. If a claimant requires a Medicare Set-Aside, the CMS review process should be completed before mediation, or at a minimum, be considered in negotiation with contingency plans in the event a review materially changes an agreement. If a client is receiving public assistance, or the settlement is anticipated to be at a level that the defense may require a structure, a broker should be available to run numbers and help make everything work. There are many more parties that may become integral to the process in certain cases, and it is critical that these parties are aware of and potentially involved in the mediation process.

At the end of the day, mediations are often unsuccessful, so the client should be prepared for that eventuality. As most mediations are voluntary, a client who is either immovable or unreasonable in their demands may seem like the last party who would benefit from mediation. However, though anecdotal, it is often these very clients who benefit most from a neutral, seasoned mediator. 

In the event of a successful mediation, settlement documents should be signed during the mediation and either physically or electronically exchanged. If there is an agreement in principle, but certain issues such as obtaining formal authority or Medicare compliance must be completed prior to executing settlement documents, the agreement should be reduced into writing, with timelines included to finalize any issues and an agreement on how to handle any potentially foreseeable changes. 

In light of the looming possibility that the Supreme Court may rule that the WCAB has lost jurisdiction on the backlog of appeals presently pending, as well as the costs and uncertainty of litigation before the courts of appeal, mediation should be considered a worthy option for all parties to explore. For the best chance at success, the client, the opposing party and the mediator should all be versed in the issues and respective positions. Perhaps this is why there has never been an episode of Perry Mason where the surprise came in mediation.

*Taylor E. Arnold is a senior associate attorney and manager of the*Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, PC*Workers’ Compensation Practice Group. Taylor has practiced Workers’ Compensation law for over a decade. He has appeared at every Workers’ Compensation appeals board in Northern California and litigated every aspect of a Workers’ Compensation case up to and including filings before the California Supreme Court.*

### [Taylor E. Arnold](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/taylor-e-arnold "Taylor E. Arnold")

[![Taylor E. Arnold](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/media/zoo/images/Arnold-Taylor-web_aedfe85d2b88a5b422ae4861542c08e8.jpg)](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/authors/taylor-e-arnold "Taylor E. Arnold")

Taylor E. Arnold is a senior associate attorney and manager of the *Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, PC* Workers’ Compensation Practice Group. Taylor has practiced workers’ compensation law for over a decade. He has appeared at every Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board in Northern California and litigated every aspect of a workers’ compensation case up to and including filings before the California Supreme Court.

### Subject Matter Index

[Client Management & Expectations](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Client%20Management?Expectations=), [Law Office Management and Technology](https://www.plaintiffmagazine.com/tag/Law%20Office%20Management%20and%20Technology)
