Jeffrey I. Ehrlich

Jeffrey I. Ehrlich

Jeffrey I. Ehrlich is the principal of the Ehrlich Law Firm in Claremont. He is a cum laude graduate of the Harvard Law School, an appellate specialist certified by the California Board of Legal Specialization, and an emeritus member of the CAALA Board of Governors. He is the editor-in-chief of Advocate magazine, a two-time recipient of the CAALA Appellate Attorney of the Year award, and in 2019 received CAOC’s Streetfighter of the Year award. Additionally, he received the Orange County Trial Lawyer’s Association Trial Lawyer of the Year award for “Distinguished Achievement” in 2023.

He is also the chair of the California Academy of Appellate Lawyers’ Task Force on Generative AI and the Law.

Articles written by this author:

Appellate Reports

Daubert error no longer requires new trial as sole remedy. Also, federal preemption ruling


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports

A review of recent decisions of interest to the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

A review of recent decisions of interest to the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

A review of recent decisions of interest to the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

A review of recent cases of interest to plaintiffs’ attorneys


Appellate reports

A review of recent cases of interest to plaintiffs’ attorneys, including the landmark State of California v. Allstate Ins. Co.


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate reports

Howell v. Hamilton Meats & Provisions, Inc. and other recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar, including Lhotka v. Geographic Expeditions, Inc. on opposing petitions to compel arbitration


Appellate reports for plaintiff attorneys

Including Hertz Corp. v. Friend: For the purposes of federal diversity jurisdiction, a corporation’s principal place of business is its “nerve center” — typically its HQ.


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Litigation privilege does not apply to conduct that is wrongful independent of the litigation


Appellate Reports and Cases in brief

Severability clauses in insurance policies will render ambiguous certain policy exclusions


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Court can deny petition to compel arbitration; also, bringing redundant causes of action in defamation suit can lead to anti-SLAPP rulings that open the door to attorney’s fees


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar



Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports

The California Supreme Court addresses the impact of the “same decision” defense in FEHA cases; notes discrimination must be “substantial factor” in termination


Rulings on federal tort claims, duty of care, corporation status, MICRA

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar.


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar.


Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar

Wrongful death and a putative spouse: California law allows a decedent’s “putative spouse” to pursue a wrongful death claim.


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Zhang clarifies many aspects of UCL practice, particularly insurance claims


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Coaching for Attorneys: Improving Productivity and Achieving Balance

A useful book for attorneys, even if you don’t like self-help books


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports

St. Mary offers clarity in responding to Requests for Admissions


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Gulliver Schools, a cautionary tale about confidentiality clauses in settlement agreements


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

New holdings on expert medical testimony in district courts and on the component-parts doctrine in state courts. Also, Ennabe v. Manosa discusses alcohol served at private parties.


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Recent opinions of the California Supreme Court, including Iskanian on employment arbitration and class-action waivers.


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Gregory v. Cott applies primary assumption of the risk to in-home health-care workers


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Patterson v. Domino’s Pizza — Franchisor tort responsibility where franchisor exhibits traditionally understood characteristics of an “employer”


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

When a lawyer sues for unpaid fees, the client complains for breach of fiduciary duty


Eight tips to keep your case in the ring

Plaintiffs seldom move for summary judgment but the defense sees it as a knockout round


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Columbo declines to rely on Exxon Shipping to cap punitive damages at the amount of compensatory damages


Appellate Reports and cases in brief

Laffitte v. Robert Half International confirms that courts in California may award class counsel a 33.33 percent fee based on common-fund recovery


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

DuBeck v. California Physician’s Service holds that an insurer who chooses to cancel a policy prospectively based on the insured’s misstatements on the application cannot thereafter rescind based on the same statements


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Amis v. Greenberg Traurig LLP confirms that all communications during mediation are subject to the mediation privilege


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Miles v. Deutsche Bank National Trust Company acknowledges that a breach-of-contract claim can be stated without attaching the contract as an exhibit or pleading its terms verbatim


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

EEOC v. Abercrombie & Fitch Stores An employer may not make an applicant’s religious practice, confirmed or otherwise, a factor in employment decisions


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Bermudez v. Ciolek Logical discussion of Howell issues concerning proof of medical expenses for an uninsured client


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Sanchez v. Valencia Holding Co. Decision by the California Supreme Court on the State’s power, in the wake of AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion to declare arbitration agreements unenforceable because they are unconscionable


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Lee v. Hanley articulates the rules governing the application of Code Civ. Proc., § 340.6, the statute of limitations for legal-malpractice claims


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

U.S. v. Moser holds that the reasons relied on by the district judge to cut the prevailing party’s fee award constituted an abuse of discretion


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Uspenskaya v. Meline - The amount a factoring company pays to purchase a medical lien is not evidence of the reasonable value of the underlying medical services


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Assumption of Risk: If you go to a haunted house, expect to be scared (Griffin v. The Haunted Hotel, Inc.)


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

A health plan’s right to reimbursement for “other equitable relief” under ERISA is limited to specific, identifiable funds within the beneficiary’s control


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports

Gaines v. Fidelity National Title Insurance makes avoiding dismissal under the 5-year rule more difficult and analyzes the rules about which periods during a lawsuit are excluded



Appellate Reports

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiff’s bar


Appellate Reports and Cases in Brief

Recent cases of interest to members of the plaintiffs’ bar


Appellate Reports

Tyson Foods v. Bouaphakeo — The U.S Supreme Court allows statistical evidence to fill evidentiary gaps in class actions


Appellate Reports

Flores v. Presbyterian − Negligent use/maintenance of certain medical equipment is subject to MICRA limitations



Appellate Reports

Ramos v. Brenntag Specialties, Inc. narrows the availability of the component parts doctrine in products-liability cases


Appellate Reports and Shorter Takes

Baral v. Schnitt — Substantially broadens the scope of the anti-SLAPP statute by holding that it can be used to attack allegations of constitutionally protected activity


Appellate Reports

Barickman v. Mercury Cas. Co. — Court rejects the insurer’s argument that it acted in good faith as a matter of law by making an early tender of policy limits


Appellate Reports

Markow v. Rosner — Appellate court isn’t buying hospital’s vicarious liability based upon ostensible agency of a physician associated with the hospital


Appellate Reports

Nickerson v. Stonebridge Ins. Co. — Affirms a punitive-damage award that is 10 times the amount of compensatory damages; holds that insurer’s claims handling was highly reprehensible


Appellate Reports

Kesner v. Superior Court — The most comprehensive discussion of the analysis of legal duty in negligence law, specifically as regards asbestos but applicable to all negligence claims where duty is an issue


Appellate Reports

Cal Supreme Court rules in Augustus v. ABM that the Brinker standard applies to rest breaks and that “on call” rest breaks are not compliant with the law


Appellate Reports

Okafor v. United States of America – Holds that a lawyer’s reliance on FedEx to timely deliver a document constitutes “routine negligence”


Appellate Reports

Claim against public entity is barred where the plaintiff failed to file a timely late-claim petition after his initial claim was deemed denied


Appellate Reports

McGill v. Citibank, NA — Allows an individual plaintiff to seek a public injunction under the UCL and FAL – relief whose primary purpose is to benefit the public generally – without the need to pursue the claim as a class action


Appellate Reports

Employment and anti-SLAPP: A decision to deny tenure rested on communications made in the course of that decision, an official proceeding, and was protected activity for purposes of anti-SLAPP


Appellate Review

Garcia v. Pexco — Defendant may enforce arbitration agreement when plaintiff alleges a defendant acted as an agent of a party to an arbitration agreement


Appellate Review

Cal Supreme Court says discovery in PAGA actions is governed by normal standards of civil litigation; supports broad view of the right to discovery in all civil cases


Be an insurance Myth Buster!

Three myths – or soon to be myths – of insurance law in California


Appellate Reports and Shorter takes

Interim adverse judgment bars malicious-prosecution claim, even if trial court later finds action was brought in bad faith


Appellate Reports

Appellate Court holds that hospital’s substantial impairment of an elderly patient’s right to autonomy can constitute actionable “neglect” within the Elder Abuse Act


Self-inflicted errors on the verdict form can torpedo your verdict

Six tips from an appellate lawyer about how to minimize the risk of inconsistent verdicts


Appellate Reports

The dangers and difficulties of trying to put “teeth” into a settlement by including provisions that increase the amount the settling defendant must pay if it fails to perform


Appellate Reports and Shorter Takes

Duty-of-care issues, particularly involving premises-liability cases where the premises abut a public street


Appellate Reports and Shorter Takes

FAA does not apply when son with power of attorney signs arbitration agreement with hospital, later sues for elder abuse in father’s death


Appellate Reports

Regents of the Univ. of California v. Superior Court (Rosen) — Holding that universities have a special relationship with their students, and therefore owe them a limited duty of care to protect them during “curricular” activities


Appellate Reports

In Dynamex Operations Cal. Supreme Court adopts new test for “employee” vs. “independent contractor.” In Pebley v. Santa Clara Organics, appellate court oks medical care on a lien, even for plaintiffs with insurance


Appellate Reports

Liberty Surplus Insurance v. Ledesma & Meyer Construction – Does an employer’s negligent hiring, retention, or supervision of an employee constitute an “accident”?


Appellate Reports

Troester v. Starbucks Corp. – The California Supreme Court rejects the use of the de minimus doctrine to allow employers to demand small amounts of uncompensated work for employees


Appellate Reports

Brady v. Bayer Corp. — Don’t call it “One A Day” vitamins and then in small print tell us we must take two; or if you prefer: one gummie a day won’t keep the rickets away


Appellate Reports

Ayon v. Esquire Deposition Solutions — Provides guidance on when credibility issues can create triable issues of fact


Appellate Reports

Court looks at standard of care that governs university’s duty to protect its students from violence. Also, primary assumption of risk in school sports


Appellate Reports

Ruling makes new law for offers and responses per CCP 998


ADP screwed up your pay check?

Look to your employer, not the payroll processor


Appellate Reports

Guernsey v. City of Salinas — When juror affidavits concerning deliberations are admissible for new-trial motions or appeal


Appellate Reports

Retroactive application of arbitration agreements in employment actions


Appellate Reports

Mazik v. Geico affirms punitive damages finding a regional manager qualified as a “managing agent”


Appellate Reports

Specific enforcement of settlement — Mesa RHF Partners, L.P. v. City of Los Angeles. Code of Civil Procedure section 664.6; requests to retain jurisdiction; signature by parties versus attorneys


Buying immunity

Buying immunity

The lid is off the policy! Can insurers immunize themselves from their bad-faith failure to settle by buying the bad-faith claim from their own policyholder?


Appellate Reports

Court says methodology of identifying class members who purchased an inflatable pool from chain store need not be shown in order to certify class. Also, decisions on choice of law and waiver of right to compel arbitration


Appellate Reports

Attorney’s potential liability under settlement signed by attorney with notation “approved as to form and content”


Appellate Reports

Defendant claims excessive verdict and that plaintiff counsel improperly pre-conditioned and engaged the passions of the jury, but Court affirms wrongful death awards totaling $45 million


Appellate Reports

Defendant claims excessive verdict and that plaintiff counsel improperly pre-conditioned and engaged the passions of the jury, but Court affirms wrongful death awards totaling $45 million


Appellate Reports

Plaintiffs’ law firm sues client for defamation in website reviews, trial court grants anti-SLAPP motion against firm, upheld on appeal


Appellate Reports

Under PAGA, employees may not seek penalties for Labor Code § 558 penalties


Appellate Reports

Path across park leading to restrooms is a “trail” for the purpose of trail immunity defense even if only occasionally used for recreational purposes


Appellate Reports

Court sees triable issue of fact as to “intolerable conditions” in constructive-termination case brought by gay CHP officer


Appellate Reports

Supreme Court holds that plaintiffs do not lose standing to pursue PAGA claims against their employer by settling their individual claims


Appellate Reports

Supreme Court holds no right to jury trial under either Unfair Competition Law or False Ad-vertising Law


Appellate Reports

Two rulings on insurance bad faith and the genuine dispute doctrine; also collateral estoppel in employment class actions


Appellate Reports

Two rulings on insurance bad faith and the genuine-dispute doctrine


Appellate Reports

Supreme Court resolves split of authority about the standard of review when standard of proof is clear-and-convincing evidence


Appellate Reports

A look at Prop 51, battery versus med mal, the sudden-emergency doctrine in auto accidents, and genuine-dispute doctrine in health insurance


Appellate Reports

Cal Supreme Court says Dynamex decision on employees vs. independent contractors is retroactive


Appellate Reports

Courts look at negligent infliction of emotional distress in the digital age; also design immunity and “home protection plans” as insurance


Appellate Reports

U.S. Supreme Court affirms state jurisdiction over alleged defective vehicles


Appellate Reports

Appellate Reports

Court publishes contempt order after attorney uses rehearing petition to rant about the legal system


Appellate Reports

Privette: The Supreme Court clarifies and narrows its exceptions


Court looks at Sanchez and case-specific hearsay

Also, non-English speakers and English-language contracts; contingency-fee agreements


Appellate Reports

Court looks at Medi-Cal liens and the published-compilation exception to the hearsay rule for evidence


Appellate Reports

Bad-faith failure to settle examined based on contract law principle; also, COVID business interruption coverage


Persuasion Science for Trial Lawyers

Deserves to join the Pantheon of trial-practice texts


Appellate Reports

Cal Supreme Court addresses whistleblowing and consequent adverse employment actions; also, Court looks at extortion by settlement demand under Flatley v. Mauro


Appellate Review

Arbitration agreements in health-care settings; also, the “baseball rule” on assumption of the risk; legal malpractice, causation and anti-SLAPP


Appellate Review

Can duress induced by a party’s own counsel void a settlement agreement?


Appellate Report

U.S. Supreme Court holds that Iskanian's rule that PAGA actions cannot be divided into individual and non-individual claims is preempted by the FAA


Appellate Report

Courts look at expert concessions on causation; also personal jurisdiction


Appellate Report

Court reviews Privette rule on retained control of job site


Appellate Report

Conditional acceptance of a 998 offer invalidates the offer as to prejudgment interest


“Accidents” and intentional conduct

“Accidents” and intentional conduct

Must an “accident” result from an unintentional act? Does negligence equate to “accident?” Strategies for dealing with “no accident, hence no coverage”


Appellate Report

Aggregated statutory damages “so severe and oppressive” held to violate due process


Appellate Report

Limits on trial court’s ability to impose sanctions for misuse of discovery


Appellate Reports

Warning labels on generic drugs; also, refusal to pay arbitration fees, and HOAs suing for construction defects


Appellate Reports

Supreme court rules governmental design immunity for dangerous roads does not categorically preclude failure-to-warn claims; also, public liability for dangerous sidewalks


Appellate Reports

In Adolph, California Supreme Court declines to follow High Court on arbitration of PAGA actions


Appellate Reports

Cal Supreme court rules on an employer’s agent’s liability in FEHA cases; also, products liability claims based on absence of a safety feature that would have prevented the accident


A first-hand experience with AI legal software

An appellate lawyer’s review of Casetext’s CoCounsel


Appellate Reports

Legal malpractice complaints and the statute of limitations; also, WC as exclusive remedy for school volunteers


Appellate Briefs

Contractors hired by DOD and removal of their complaints to federal court. Also, premises liability and the negligent undertaking theory; and, reduction of attorney fees based on incivility of counsel


Appellate Briefs

MICRA and ambulances involved in auto accidents; also, PAGA waivers, the trivial-defect doctrine


Appellate Reports

Relief from waiver of jury trial; also Labor Code and pay stubs, hotels and premises liability


Appellate Reports

Medical-expense damages and the collateral-source rule/Medicare; also, handwritten vs. electronic signatures on arbitration agreements, and scam ads on Facebook, binding arbitration agreements and wrongful-death heirs


Appellate Reports

After State Farm denies homeowner’s claim, contract and bad-faith suit is barred by statute of limitations, but suit for unfair business practice under UCL can go forward


Appellate Review

Lemon Law: a “new motor vehicle” means a vehicle sold by a new-car dealer for the first time, not just one sold with an unexpired manufacturer’s warranty. Also, judicial- disqualification motions


A primer on fire-insurance coverage in California

The issues consumers will face as they try to rebuild their homes and lives


Appellate Reports

Privette and its applicability to indirect owner of hirer. Also, sports and assumption of the risk; dangers alongside high-speed roadways


Appellate Reports

Insurance coverage for cleaning-up smoke and debris when premises do not burn; also, head injury in football and assumption of the risk doctrine


Appellate Reports

Decisions involving legal malpractice, waiver of arbitration, and insurance bad faith


Appellate Reports

FEHA attorney’s fees; also, discovery abuse, and medical malpractice


AI in the courts

AI in the courts

Judicial decisions dealing with AI-related issues


A guide for lawyers to understanding how LLMs work

A guide for lawyers to understanding how LLMs work

Large Language Models are revolutionizing the legal profession, offering transformative potential when used safely and ethically


Appellate Briefs

MICRA and claims based on generally applicable duties of care, as opposed to “professional negligence”


Appellate Reports

Trial judge is the best judge of reasonable hourly rates for trial attorneys. Arbitration: the need to show signed arbitration agreement defendant relies on. Also, good faith settlement findings and motions to amend judgment


Appellate Reports

Prohibited retaliation against whistleblowers


Appellate Reports

How Berk v. Choy validates 25 years of Ninth Circuit dissents



Appellate Reports

Attorney fee disputes and declaratory relief; also, do contracts that specify the arbitration forum as JAMS unmistakenly delegate the right to determine the enforceability of the arbitration clause?


Appellate Reports

The “two dismissal rule” is not a rule of claim preclusion; also, the Ending Forced Arbitration of Sexual Assault/Harassment Act; and, self-represented plaintiffs can get mandatory sanction for defendant’s discovery abuse


Appellate Reports

Duty of care in drug development; also, insurance policy- limit demands and summary judgment