We go to trial confident that we will win on each question presented to the jury. The questions we are asking the jury to resolve are almost always presented through a special verdict form. For each cause of action, the special verdict form asks the jury to resolve factual questions that, if determined in our favor, will support entry of judgment for our clients. But what happens when the jury makes findings that support entry of judgment in our favor on one cause of action, but deadlocks on another? What will almost certainly happen is that defense counsel will argue that the entire case needs to be retried. For good reason, that is not the law in California, and this article discusses the authority of a trial court to enter a partial verdict on a resolved cause of action, while ordering a retrial limited to the cause of action on which the jury has deadlocked.
Special verdict forms
Special verdict forms are used in almost every trial. While the Code of Civil Procedure allows for general verdict forms – where the jury, in essence, declares one side a winner and one side a loser – such forms are rarely, if ever, used. With a general verdict form, there is an implied finding of all facts in favor of the prevailing party. (Taylor v. Nabors Drilling USA (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1228, 1242.) Defense counsel would prefer to have the different fact questions broken out into specific questions, creating more opportunity for a defense verdict. Special verdict forms are standard practice largely for this reason.
A special verdict form asks the jury to decide factual questions for each cause of action, the resolution of which will allow the court to enter judgment. Code of Civil Procedure section 624 states that the questions in a special verdict form “must be so presented as that nothing shall remain to the Court but to draw from them conclusions of law.” (Code Civ. Proc., § 624.) A special verdict form is “fatally defective” if it does not ask the jury to resolve each contested issue. (Saxena v. Goffney (2008) 159 Cal.App.4th 316, 325.) The special verdict form must be drafted such that once the questions presented are answered, all that is left for the trial court is to enter judgment.
Courts have observed that one of the “recognized pitfalls” of a special verdict form is that “it requires the jury to resolve all of the controverted issues in the case, unlike a general verdict, which merely implies findings on all issues in one party’s favor.” (Taylor v. Nabors Drilling USA (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1228, 1242.) But what is meant by “all of the controverted issues in the case” requires further analysis, particularly with respect to special verdict forms that present multiple causes of action.
“All or nothing” is not the law
One possible interpretation is that if the jury hangs on any of the questions presented to it in the special form, then no verdict can be entered. In other words, even if the jury resolves questions sufficient for judgment on one cause of action, no verdict can be entered if the jury deadlocks on questions required for entry of another cause of action. While this is an argument that defense counsel will make, it is not the law. The Courts of Appeal have repeatedly recognized that a partial verdict may be entered where the jury has resolved all questions sufficient to permit entry of judgment on one or more causes of action, regardless of whether the jury has hung on other causes of action.
The “all or nothing” view on special verdict forms is directly at odds with settled case law. The Courts of Appeal have recognized that “[t]here is no constitutional impediment to retrial of a limited issue, so long as that issue is sufficiently distinct and severable from the others that a limited retrial would not result in an injustice.” (Valentine v. Baxter Healthcare Corp. (1999) 68 Cal.App.4th 1467, 1478.)
No statutory language
While there is no specific statutory language that authorizes a trial court to enter a partial verdict, the Courts of Appeal have explained that this power accords with a trial court’s ability to “partially resolve the issues before it.” (Valentine, supra, 68 Cal.App.4th at 1477.) Among other things, trial courts have the authority to grant a new trial on partial issues, to grant a partial judgment notwithstanding the verdict, and to grant nonsuit as to some causes of action. (Id. at 1475-77.) The ability to enter a partial verdict is consistent with each of these powers to partially resolve issues before the court. (Ibid.) And the reason for recognizing such a power is straightforward: Retrying an entire case when there has been a jury finding sufficient to support a partial verdict would “add to the burden of already overcrowded court calendars and could be unduly harsh on the parties.” (Little v. Superior Court (1961) 55 Cal.2d 642, 645.)
The Courts of Appeal have accordingly recognized that partial verdicts may be entered based on a special form where the jury has made sufficient findings to support judgment on at least one cause of action. (See, e.g., Valentine, supra, 68 Cal.App.4th at 1475-77; Cruz v. HomeBase (2000) 83 Cal.App.4th 160, 163.) These courts have explained that a trial court may enter a “partial special verdict” where the jury has resolved all facts necessary on a “separate and severable” cause of action. (Valentine, supra, 68 Cal.App.4th at 1477-1480.) Where “special verdicts on one matter do not depend on inconclusive verdicts on another matter, the remaining matter can properly be determined on retrial.” (Id. at 1478.)
In Cruz v. HomeBase, for example, the jury found for the plaintiff on his battery claim, but it hung on his false imprisonment and malicious prosecution claims. (Cruz, supra, 83 Cal.App.4th at 163.) The trial court declared a mistrial as to the unresolved claims, and ordered a retrial limited to those claims. On appeal, the defendant argued that “the partial retrial ordered by the trial court was improper.” (Id. at 165.) The Court of Appeal rejected this argument, explaining that the trial court was within its authority to enter the partial verdict. “When a jury decides fewer than all causes of action, the trial court may order a retrial addressing only the unresolved claims if the issues are distinct and retrial works no injustice.” (Id. at 165.) In the Court of Appeal’s view, the question of whether the causes of action were sufficiently separate and distinct was straightforward because “[t]he legal elements and facts on which each tort rested were separate and distinct.” (Id. at 166.) This ground alone was sufficient to support entry of the partial verdict.
Whether claims are sufficiently “separate and distinct” to support a partial verdict of course depends on the particulars of the case. But the “different legal elements and facts” standard applied in Cruz should be persuasive to most courts. Relatedly, a punitive damages claim should also be treated as separate and distinct because a different evidentiary burden applies, in addition to the jury having to make specific findings of fact. (There is also ample authority recognizing that a court may order a retrial on the limited issue of punitive damages.) (See, e.g., Torres v. Auto. Club of So. California (1997) 15 Cal. 4th 771, 776 [“appellate courts have not hesitated to remand cases for retrial limit to punitive damages”].)
At bottom, this is a commonsense inquiry: If a claim stands on its own, a jury’s findings on that claims should result in entry of a partial verdict on that claim.
The limited scope of Falls v. Superior Ct.
Falls v. Superior Ct. (1987) 194 Cal.App.3d 851 is a case that often comes up in the context of splitting a special verdict. There, the Court of Appeal, using broad language, held that the special verdict form at issue in that case could not be split. The opinion can easily be misconstrued for the proposition that a special verdict form cannot be split if there is any unresolved question. The facts of the case, however, make clear that the Court of Appeal was not speaking so broadly.
Falls was a slip-and-fall case where the plaintiff slipped on spilled motor oil on the way into an auto store. At trial, the verdict form asked the jury to decide both whether the defendant auto store was negligent and whether the plaintiff was negligent. The jury agreed that the defendant was negligent and the cause of injury but hung on damages. Because the jury hung the section of the form relating to defendant’s negligence, it did not reach the questions on the verdict form that asked the jury to decide whether the plaintiff also bore fault, and if so, the extent to which any recovery should be reduced.
After the jury returned its partial verdict, the plaintiff asked the trial court to enter a partial verdict on liability and proximate cause, while the defense argued no verdict should be entered at all. The trial court ruled in favor of the defense, declaring a mistrial on the ground that “the jury had not determined sufficient ultimate facts” on which a partial verdict could be entered.
The plaintiff then filed a writ of mandate to compel the trial court to enter a partial verdict. The Court of Appeal denied the petition. It explained that the jury must resolve all “ultimate facts presented to it in the special verdict, so that ‘nothing shall remain to the court but to draw from them conclusions of law.’” (Id. at 854-855, citing Code Civ. Proc., § 624.) The Court of Appeal explained that while the jury found the defendant acted negligently, it did not fully resolve the issue of liability, because it made no determinations as to plaintiff’s comparative negligence. In other words, the jury had not made sufficient findings to support entry of judgment on the plaintiff’s negligence claim. As the Court put it, “The liability issue as it now stands is like a puzzle with pieces missing; the picture is not complete.” (Id. at 855.) The Court also pointed out the prejudice likely to result to defendant in a retrial: The jury would be asked to resolve whether the plaintiff was negligent, despite being instructed that the defendant’s negligence had already been determined. (Ibid.)
Falls is in no way inconsistent with the settled rule that a trial court can enter a partial verdict on a discrete cause of action. What drove the Falls decision was that the jury had not reached defendant’s comparative fault claim. As a result, the jury had not resolved all of the questions sufficient for a partial verdict to be entered on the plaintiff’s negligent claim. The case also had a unique fairness concern involving a retrial on the question of the plaintiff’s negligence, where the jury would be instructed that the defendant’s negligence had already been determined. In short, while Falls may have been correctly decided on its particular facts, it does not stand for the broader proposition that a special verdict form can never be split, although defense counsel often cite it for this very proposition.
Pushing the law forward: Partial verdict on issues within a cause of action
The case law is clear that where a jury’s findings on a special verdict form are sufficient to support judgment on one (or more) cause(s) of action, the trial court can enter a partial verdict, even if the jury has deadlocked on other causes of action. A question that does not appear to have been directly confronted by the Courts of Appeal is whether a trial court can enter a partial verdict on an issue within a cause of action.
Take for example a negligence claim where the jury finds in favor of the plaintiff on duty and breach, but it hangs on causation. Assuming there is no comparative fault claim as in Falls, can the trial court enter a partial verdict on duty and breach, while ordering a limited retrial on causation and damages? The case law discussed throughout this article contemplates jury findings on the entire cause of action. But the reasoning underlying a trial court’s authority to enter a partial verdict on a discrete cause of action would apply equally to issues within a cause of action.
There are a variety of procedural tools that enable a trial court to carve up causes of actions: motions for judgments on the pleadings, motions for summary adjudication, and motions for partial verdict are some examples. A jury’s verdict should be no different. If a jury has determined duty and breach, partial verdict should be entered on those issues to avoid the inefficiency and unfairness of an entire new trial on them. The court, the parties, and the jury all invest substantial time and resources to resolve disputed questions through a trial. The determinations that the jury makes should not be treated as dust in the wind simply because it does not resolve all the questions presented to it. Trials are about resolving factual disputes, and the factual determinations that are made should be honored, whether or not they are sufficient to resolve an entire cause of action.
Bill Foster is an associate at Pillsbury & Coleman LLP who represents clients in insurance coverage and bad faith actions.
