American Association for Justice
The Monsanto v. Durnell U.S. Supreme Court decision in June immunizes manufacturers of dangerous pesticide products from accountability in state failure-to-warn cases. In addition to pesticides like Roundup, the decision immunizes the manufacturers of more than 57,000 products commonly found in homes, schools, and workplaces from accountability. This decision shields corporate chemical companies, weakens longstanding legal protections, and tramples every state’s right to protect its own citizens.
The American Association for Justice issued a statement, calling on Congress to restore the rights of people who will have limited paths for justice and accountability. Corporate chemical companies have, for years, sought immunity legislation, and they have been overwhelmingly rejected in red and blue states alike.
Case in point: Earlier in June, the North Carolina Senate defeated a pesticide immunity provision in the North Carolina Farm Act (SB 401). North Carolina was the final state with pesticide immunity legislation that AAJ was monitoring in the 2026 legislative sessions; this year, pesticide immunity legislation was defeated in nine of ten states where it was introduced.
AAJ’s commitment to protecting people from harmful products and defending the right to seek accountability remains resolute. We will continue working to ensure that the voices of those harmed by dangerous pesticides are heard.
Pesticide immunity proposals in Congress
As we previously reported, lawmakers in the U.S. House voted in favor of an amendment to remove immunity for pesticide companies from the House Farm Bill. This was a decisive, bipartisan vote of 280 to 142, with 73 Republicans voting to remove immunity. This vote effectively removed a provision that would have shielded corporate chemical companies from accountability.
And on the Senate side, its version of the Farm Bill does not include pesticide immunity.
What we have seen and heard at both the state and federal levels is that there are many voices and groups – across the political spectrum – joining in broad opposition to pesticide immunity.
Uber and ride-hail corporations seek immunity
The toughest battle we fight is against powerful corporations and industries that want to preempt all state tort liability. No area of plaintiff trial law is truly safe.
On May 22, legislation that includes an amendment to eliminate nearly all claims for ride-hail companies like Uber and Lyft advanced through the House Transportation Committee in the BUILD America 250 Act.
AAJ vigorously opposed this provision, as well as an amendment immunizing peer-to-peer car rental companies such as Turo, and a provision removing any legal obligation to recall and repair defects labeled “optional” on rented or leased commercial vehicles.
AAJ worked to ensure that many other problematic provisions, including broker-shipper immunity and several measures restricting remedies, were not included in the bill, and we are continuing to work to prevent this legislation from advancing further.
On June 17, nearly 1,900 survivors of sexual assault and rape sent a letter to Congress to oppose the proposal that would eliminate nearly all claims against ride-hail companies. It makes an enormous difference when lawmakers hear directly from people who have been impacted.
Amicus Curiae updates
Notwithstanding the decision in Monsanto v. Durnell, since January 2026, in cases of significance to AAJ’s mission and its members, the U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) has ruled in favor of AAJ’s position nine times, with eight of those being unanimous decisions.
On June 11, the SCOTUS ruled unanimously in favor of the plaintiff in Keathley v. Buddy Ayers Construction, Inc., 608 U.S. In Keathley, AAJ filed an amicus brief highlighting the flimsy historical background of judicial estoppel, which Justice Thomas cited in his concurrence.
Federal Rules updates
The Committee on Practice and Procedure met in Chicago in June and approved several amendments that will take effect on December 1, 2027:
- 7.1 (Disclosure)
- 41(a) (Voluntary Dismissal by Plaintiff)
- 45(b) (Serving a Subpoena)
- 45(c) (Subpoena for Remote Testimony)
- 81(c) (Demand for a Jury Trial)
- FRAP 29 (Amicus Briefs)
The Committee approved proposed amendments for the 2026-2027 comment period, including amendments to privacy rules for civil, criminal, and bankruptcy rules. AAJ supports these amendments, which would remove social security numbers and require the use of pseudonyms for minors.
Keeping vigilant
In order to prevail so that injured people can continue to seek justice in the courts, we must be vigilant. AAJ is monitoring state and federal legislation, building consensus among diverse groups. We’re filing amicus briefs not only in the U.S. Supreme Court, but also in appellate and state courts, prioritizing cases that present significant interest to the trial bar. We’re actively working in the federal rules arena to ensure that the plaintiff voice is represented as we advocate for fair and balanced rules. Through this comprehensive approach, we remain strong, moving forward in the fight for accountability for all plaintiff lawyers and their clients.