2026 May

I prepared for my first ever trial, 44 years ago, representing a client in a fraud claim in Bankruptcy Court. The trial judge was the father of a childhood best friend, so he knew me, which compounded the humiliation that was to come.

My client was an old guy who had brokered the sale of a professional practice and got stiffed on his commission when the buyer sued the seller for fraud and the seller filed for bankruptcy. Our claim was that the seller’s obligation to pay the commission was not dischargeable in bankruptcy.

I liked my client. Better than that, he told a very compelling story. I met with him several times during the course of the case. He always told me the exact same, compelling story. Because it was such a good story I recall taking the case on a contingent-fee basis. Which is another thing I wouldn’t do 44 years later. My client was never deposed in the case.

One essential element of a fraud claim is that the plaintiff actually and justifiably relied on the alleged fraudulent misrepresentations, in this case by the seller who had retained the broker. Every time I asked my client about whether he relied on the misrepresentations, he said he did and articulated persuasive reasons for why he relied upon them and how this reliance caused him to be the broker in the transaction and caused him the harm of not being paid.

The trial begins

As the trial began, I gave a short opening statement, largely stating the story my client had told me, which was what the evidence would show. So far, so good. The other side made a short opening statement. It was now 10:00 a.m.

My first witness was my client, the plaintiff. After leading him through the background facts, we got to the heart of the story. He testified about what the seller represented to him and how he later learned how those misrepresentations were false. Again, so far, so good.

Then we came to the reliance part. I asked him whether he had relied on the seller’s misrepresentations, expecting to hear the same story I had heard multiple times over the year of representing him. Then it went something like:

Me: Did you rely on the representations of the seller that you have told us were false?

Him: No.

Here, my memory gets fuzzy. I am certain that I tried to ask him the same thing some other way. This did no good. When I tried a third time, the judge gave me a stern look, warning me against coaching. I tried moving on and then coming back to the reliance question, to no avail. It was 10:30. I had nothing more I could ask him that the judge wouldn’t consider time wasting. There was little chance of asking for and getting a recess. I couldn’t credibly feign a need to use the restroom. It was my first ever trial. Everything moved fast and while today I know how to slow things down, I didn’t have that knowledge 44 years ago. Otherwise, I would have insisted on a recess.

I had no idea what to do and the judge seemed amused to see his son’s friend struggle. I finished my direct examination, having failed to establish an essential element of my client’s claim with the only possible competent witness who could testify firsthand about reliance. Opposing counsel did not bother to cross-examine. The judge had a funny look on his face.

“Why would you say that?”

After my client left the stand, the judge mercifully called a recess. I hustled my client out into the hall, hoping there was something I could say to save the situation. In a forceful voice I asked the client why he said he had not relied on the misrepresentations, which was the opposite of what he had told me several times over the last year.

My client said simply, “Well, this morning I was sworn to tell the truth.” He did not seem contrite, or that he was aware that he had sabotaged his case by not telling me the truth from the beginning. I remained bewildered. It took several minutes before I realized that the oath he took in court was much more real to him than the interviews I had with him. It did not seem to bother him that he lost the case. He owed me no money.

We went back into court. I closed my case in chief. I had no other evidence to present. A motion for nonsuit was made and granted. Unlike Perry Mason, I now had lost a trial.

The learning moment for me is a promise to myself that the toughest cross-examination my clients will ever get is from me.

P.S. – Clients take the oath seriously. In a jury trial 20 years later in a rural California county, my client, my first witness, surprised me and the jury by refusing to take the oath. My client had some problem with the “So help me God” part. I don’t remember why. We totally got off on the wrong foot and never got off of the wrong foot. It was my first loss of a jury case. Now I ask clients if they will have any problem taking the oath, which no longer references God.

John D. Moore is Of Counsel to the Helbraun Law Firm, San Francisco.  He is Board Certified in Civil Trial Law by the National Board of Trial Advocacy.  A trial veteran since 1980, John received a Distinguished Service Award in 2023 by the Almeda County Bar Association.