This year introduced some big changes in the world of subrogation in third-party personal injury claims involving peace officers and firefighters.
Most civil litigators are all too familiar with the concept of subrogation. For those who are not as familiar, it is essentially the process where one party, usually an insurance company, assumes the legal rights of another to collect debt and/or damages. This legal doctrine is a tool that allows insurance companies to quickly pay out claims to their policy holders and pursue reimbursement from the at-fault party’s insurance.
In workers’ compensation, we see this frequently when an employee is involved in an on-duty accident involving a third party. A common scenario is a police officer involved in an on-duty motor vehicle accident involving a third party, who later pursues both workers’ compensation benefits and civil damages.
In these types of claims, it is commonly understood that the workers’ compensation carrier or employer is entitled to a reimbursement for whatever benefits it provided before a claimant recovers a civil settlement.
There are, of course, some protections and limitations against employers/insurers obtaining total reimbursement for their lien. The common fund doctrine provides that an employer’s/insurer’s lien should be reduced by a fair share of attorneys’ fees and litigation expenses. The statutory framework for this doctrine is provided under Labor Code sections 3856 and 3860. Additionally, where appropriate, if an employee is able to show employer negligence, their reimbursement and credit rights are reduced or eliminated in proportion to their percentage of comparative fault.
New Law: Senate Bill 487
Senate Bill 487 (“SB 487”), which was signed into law on October 13, 2025 and effective January 1, 2026, changed this landscape for injured peace officers and firefighters.
SB 487 makes the recovery of a workers’ compensation lien much more complicated and restrictive for the employer or carrier in the case of an injured peace officer/firefighter.
Workers’ compensation subrogation is governed primarily by Labor Code sections 3850 to 3865. SB 487 amended six of these sections of the Labor Code, changing subrogation rights of employers/insurers in three fundamental ways: (1) SB 487 limits the amount of reimbursement or lien an employer/insurer can obtain from a third-party settlement; (2) SB 487 eliminated automatic credit rights and offset against future workers’ compensation benefits; and (3) SB 487 allows more freedom for injured workers to settle their third-party case without requiring prior consent (with some limitations).
Two-thirds recovery for peace officer/firefighter; one-third cap for employer
SB 487 amended Labor Code section 3852 to state that in claims involving a peace officer/firefighter, an employer/insurer shall be entitled to receive no more than one-third of a third-party defendant’s applicable liability insurance policy limits if the following is true: (1) the employee established their total damages exceed the net recovery after satisfaction of the employer’s claim; and (2) the total liability insurance limits are insufficient to fully compensate both the employer and employee’s proven damages.
This provides a two-thirds recovery allocation to injured peace officers/firefighters.
Pursuant to the Labor Code, the maximum one-third recovery shall apply to all settlement agreements and judgments and take precedence over any employer lien or subrogation claim.
Entitlement to future benefits without credit
Prior to SB 487, the Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board was authorized to credit the employer with an amount equal to the employee’s third-party net recovery (after attorneys’ fees and litigation costs) from a personal injury settlement. Specifically, the employer/insurer could claim a statutory future credit against its obligation to pay ongoing medical care and disability benefits equal to the injured worker’s net recovery. This would essentially pause future benefits until the value of benefits surpass the credit amount.
SB 487 amended Labor Code section 3862, prohibiting employers/insurers from asserting a credit or offset against a peace officer’s/firefighter’s future workers’ compensation benefit when they have recovered from a third party.
Under the workers’ compensation system, an injured worker is entitled to all medical care that is reasonably required to cure or relieve the effects of the industrial injury. The entitlement to medical care for an industrial injury is arguably the most valuable benefit in the workers’ compensation system. This medical care is a lifetime benefit that covers not only the injury, but any compensable consequences thereof.
SB 487 prohibition against this credit toward future benefits is a huge win for peace officers/firefighters. It provides an additional layer of protection for any future medical care needs; the severity of which often cannot be fully appreciated at the time of settlement.
Prior consent
Previously, Labor Code section 3859 required notice and written consent of both the employer and employee, for a third-party settlement/release to be valid.
SB 487 explicitly amended Labor Code section 3589 to allow autonomy for first responders to resolve their civil, third-party liability claims independently without waiting for permission or approval from the employer/insurer.
Conclusion
SB 487 has made significant changes to the Labor Code. When it comes to first responders, employers/insurers lien rights to reimbursement and future credits are now limited. When handling a third-party civil case, both workers’ compensation and civil practitioners should be aware of this important change which allows much greater recovery and medical coverage protection for their first responder clients.
Jessica E. Berlat is a senior associate in the Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver, PC Workers’ Compensation Practice Group. Jessica’s practice primarily focuses on the representation of first responders, police officers and firefighters. Jessica specializes in handling complicated injuries often contested as industrially related. She has expertise in Labor Code presumptions, Northern California Alternative Dispute Resolution programs, and workers’ compensation claims and retirement. Jessica has successfully assisted many qualified clients through the disability retirement pension process.
