2026 November

Todd A. Porter was drawn to plaintiff law after seeing how difficult it can be for patients to get insurance authorization for medical procedures. It just didn’t sit right with him. Representing plaintiffs in life-altering personal-injury cases seemed like a good way to use his inborn debate and storytelling skills.

“I think there’s more opportunity to bring access to justice through storytelling and, at the same time, throw a lance through the heart of insurance companies,” Porter said in a recent interview with Plaintiff magazine.

Porter has now practiced law for 36 years, including 30 years as the sole proprietor of the Morro Bay-based Law Office of Todd A. Porter. He holds an AV Preeminent peer rating from Martindale-Hubbell, a distinction held by just five percent of U.S. lawyers, based on professional excellence and high ethical standards.

The boutique practice’s caseload includes significant personal injury, wrongful death, and elder and dependent-adult abuse and neglect.

“I handle a small number of cases to try to give them an extraordinary amount of attention to achieve exceptional results,” he said. “I provide access to justice for persons who might not otherwise get it.”

He cites among his most memorable cases Kathleen A. Reed and Alexander F. Arcady vs. Genesis Corp., et al., in which a 33-year-old developmentally disabled adult died at the hands of her caretakers. The caregivers allegedly restrained the woman to the point of suffocation after a brief struggle but didn’t attempt to resuscitate her with CPR. A jury in San Luis Obispo Superior Court awarded $7.7 million to the woman’s parents in their wrongful-death and dependent-adult-abuse lawsuit against the caregivers’ employer.

In that lawsuit, Porter served as co-counsel alongside attorney James R. Murphy, Jr. of personal injury law firm Murphy Barron Law, LLP in Arroyo Grande. The case earned the pair the Central Coast Trial Lawyers of the Year award in 2013.

“It was an enormously challenging case. The jury came back and awarded more in damages than was asked for in the closing, which was remarkable,” Porter recalled.

The case was emotional for everyone involved. After the verdict, Judge Charles S. Crandall told the jurors they could speak to the lawyers. In what Porter describes as the most impactful moment of his career, the jurors elected to use their time to offer condolences to the victim’s parents.

“All the women on the jury, every one of them, lined up to hold and hug and cry with my clients,” Porter recalled. “I was just blown away by that.”

Currently, Porter is working on an electrical-shock case out of Hayward, set for a jury trial in March 2027. That case involves an HVAC technician who was electrocuted on the job when he made contact with a metal conduit that was wrongly energized. He survived, but was hospitalized with serious injuries.

That case has compelled Porter to spend many hours on research, including watching YouTube videos of electricians explaining the finer details of grounding and bonding.

“It’s not to become an expert, but it is to develop a vocabulary so that I can both interact with experts on the subject and then communicate it to laypersons,” Porter said.

Keeping busy

Porter studied law at the University of the Pacific McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento. He began his legal career at Ray A. Gallo’s law firm in Los Osos, where Porter got his first taste of plaintiff and family law. When he went solo six years later, Porter took on a mix of plaintiff and family law cases to keep his docket full.

While he learned a lot about communication and empathy while practicing family law, he considers it a perilous environment. “It’s where people go crazy and crazy people get dangerous because there’s just so, so much going on,” he said.

While Porter most often works alone, he’s collaborated with other lawyers on complex cases and counts Gallo and Murphy among his most cherished mentors.

“We’ve collaborated on a number of cases together, and that has been a huge part of my professional development,” Porter said. “I’m very confident in my own abilities, but I look at Jim [Murphy] and think, he’s always been a sort of next-level lawyer.”

Most of Porter’s legal work comes to him by word of mouth, since he doesn’t maintain a significant online presence.  “I’ve always liked flying under the radar. I don’t like advertising,” he said.

When work was slow amid the Covid-19 closures, he completed a virtual training program to become certified as an impartial workplace investigator. In that capacity, he can offer California companies impartial investigations into internal workplace complaints, such as ethics violations or discrimination.

He’s also picked up assignments as a judge pro tempore, taking on small claims calendars for the court as needed.

Porter said that his tasks as an impartial workplace investigator and as a judge pro tem have informed his vocation as a plaintiff attorney.

“Training as a neutral has been enormously beneficial in terms of developing my skill set as an advocate,” he explained. “Having been in the shoes of the neutral and understanding what a neutralist really is trying to do and the constraints and limits on their ability to do it has been enormously impactful in my preparation and deliveries and advocacy.”

Porter said he’s learned that brevity and preparation can be an advantage when he’s in front of a judge with a busy calendar.

“The biggest constraint on judicial decision-making is time. As a plaintiff’s lawyer, you know you need to be concise, tight, prepared, and really efficient with your time,” Porter said.

Higher education

Porter gives back to the lawyering community by counseling undergraduate students on whether law school is a good fit for them, where and how to apply, and how to maintain their mental and physical health as both law students and young professionals.

“This profession involves a lot of stress and conflict, so you have to have a plan. It’s going to be different for each person,” he said. “Have I always been great at that? No. Have I learned from my mistakes? Yes.”

He worked as an instructor at California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo for more than five years, teaching political science topics including judicial process, jurisprudence, judicial politics, and mock trial. He estimates he instructed more than 600 students and has written 26 letters of recommendation to the Law School Admission Council for former students.

“It is 100 percent impossible to be depressed when you are around young people who have all this excitement and energy for what they’re doing,” he said. “I tell them, ‘You know, you are the sun to my solar panels.’ They recharge me.”

Porter earned his bachelor’s degree from Cal Poly San Luis Obispo and returned in 2014 for a master’s degree in public policy.

“In terms of work-life balance, I’ve always kind of needed to step away from the practice of law. And when I state ‘step away,’ I still practice, but I do things outside the practice of law for some balance to my life, and that’s taken different shapes and different forms.”

He’s coached youth sports and self-published a 93-page leadership book, called “Better Together,” based on that experience. He also narrated the audiobook version.

His time as a graduate student was another means to combat burnout. He made connections with faculty who suggested he try his hand at teaching.

“The interesting thing about all those different things, whether it was coaching or teaching, is they all involve communication, and they all made me a more balanced person and a better communicator,” he said.

Finding balance

Maintaining that work-life balance is a key component of his advice to young lawyers. 

“One thing that I’ve mentioned to students is that this practice of law, strangely, can be very isolating. We’re obviously dealing with people and communicating, but you sort of have your head down in your files,” he said. “I think it’s very important to have other parts of your life where you’re socially interacting.”

Porter said his downtime has changed with the passage of time. When his three children were young, his social life revolved around their activities. Now that they’re grown, he swims, hikes, and spends time with his two grandchildren.

“I thought, what would be cool for my grandkids and me to do and get good at? So, I’ve been playing guitar for a year and enjoying that,” he said. “Right now, my audience is a 2-year-old grandson and a cat.”

Porter also lends his time to organizations including the San Luis Obispo Legal Assistance Foundation and the Legal Aid Association of Santa Barbara County, particularly as the legal help applies to seniors and other vulnerable populations.

Fellow attorneys often ask him to speak on the Elder Abuse Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act, specifically as it relates to financial elder abuse.

Looking ahead, he’s considered putting some of his best college lecture material online to reach a wider audience. And he’s also always on the search for the next engaging, impactful plaintiff law case.

“I’m always looking for a great story,” he said.  “When I’m evaluating a case, it’s always in terms of what I do in collaboration with my client. I make sure they understand. I say, ‘I’m your lawyer, and I’m going to do this work for you, but we’re collaborating together, and we’re going to breathe life into the story.’”

Jennifer McEntee is a freelance writer based in San Diego.