It’s a nice fall morning in early October. The defense lawyer just drove 90 minutes from the Bay Area to your modest office. It’s the same drive she makes with her family on winter weekends to go skiing. The defendant arrives a few minutes later. He remembers the criminal defense attorney who used to work in this office and helped his son years ago with a DUI. He remembers how that lawyer helped his family during a tough time. Your casually dressed staff greet them and treat them well, showing them where the restrooms are and offering water or coffee. The courthouse is across the street. The deposition takes place in your conference room. Ninety minutes later, you have the admissions you need, and they shake your hand on the way out. You are professional, prepared, and fair. That says a lot about small-town practice without having to announce it.
The home-field advantage
Doing the deposition in person has a subtle psychological advantage, along with some practical ones. The defense lawyer and deponent leave with an impression that we are professional, prepared, and fair – and that we actually work in the community where the case will be tried. Sitting across the conference table with the courthouse outside makes the litigation a little more real.
There are practical benefits too. Zoom is great for efficiency, and we use it all the time. But we’ve all taken the deposition where the witness has a terrible internet connection, is staring up at us from an iPhone, or can’t see the exhibit we are sharing. Sometimes it’s just better to sit across the table, put the document in front of the witness, watch them study it, and ask the question.
And there is one final advantage to taking the deposition at home. The defense lawyer has now been to your office. They have met your staff. They have seen your operation. They have driven past the businesses where potential jurors shop and eat and, in our case, looked across the street at the courthouse where the case will eventually be tried. None of that wins a case. But it quietly communicates something important: we are not parachuting into this community for a lawsuit. We live here, we work here, and if the case needs to be tried here, we will be right at home.
Repetition creates institutional knowledge and gets stuff done
Another advantage to working in a smaller community is repetition. I repeatedly sue some of the same institutional defendants for the same types of claims. My hope is that we’re making a difference, and I’ve seen firsthand that we are. I’ve sued Caltrans over dangerous roadway conditions along the Highway 49 corridor between Auburn and Grass Valley on several occasions, and over the years I’ve watched significant safety improvements take shape along that corridor.
In other cases, I’ve seen sidewalks and stairs replaced, signs installed, and dangerous trees trimmed or removed. Big firms take on corporate giants and make products and business practices safer. That’s rad. On a micro-scale, small-town lawyers can do the same thing in their own communities.
Repetition also tells us where the evidence is. I’ve sued the same corporate supermarket in my town at least three times. I know its video-retention policy. I know the store manager and assistant manager. I know what should happen after a fall and what reports should exist. When the discovery responses come back, I have a pretty good idea of what I’m looking for and, sometimes more importantly, what’s missing. That’s a legitimate competitive advantage. And by now, management at that store should know who we are too.
Each case makes our discovery in the next one a little better. But familiarity is an advantage only until it becomes an assumption. We can’t get lazy. I’ve learned things in later-stage depositions that made me wish I’d asked for a particular document six months earlier. We try to carry those lessons into the next case. The trick is using what we learned last time without assuming this time will be the same.
Have you seen this before?
We share information with other plaintiff firms, and they share with us. It’s a great practice. It gives us access to discovery, motions, experts, and experience we otherwise might not have. We also co-counsel with other firms on the right cases. Those relationships, particularly with larger firms in the “big city,” have tremendously helped our firm.
Our friends at larger firms have fought the protective-order battle before. They’ve briefed the discovery issue. They’ve deposed the corporate witness. They’ve seen the defense expert. They may have exemplar motions, orders, deposition outlines, or discovery that saves us from reinventing the wheel. Sometimes all I need to do is pick up the phone and ask, “Have you seen this before?”
The relationship runs both ways. They have scale; we have local knowledge. We know the courthouse, jury pool, community, local witnesses, medical providers, businesses, roads, and personalities. Not every case requires a deep bench, but it’s nice to know one is there when we need it.
And there is something satisfying about a large defense firm getting discovery from a small firm in Auburn, seeing us follow up when something is missing, and then seeing us actually file the motion. At some point, I like to think somebody on the other side says, “Okay... these guys have some game.”
Homecoming
So, to the small-town lawyer out there, I say this: You could have left. Plenty of professionals from small towns do. But small communities don’t work if everybody leaves to get educated and then takes those skills somewhere else. Somebody has to come home and be the doctor, lawyer, teacher, accountant, contractor, or business owner.
You came home. You’ve made a living there. You’ve put some of that money back into the place – buildings, employees, youth sports, community organizations. So, when a defendant walks into your office for a deposition, they’re not walking into some temporary litigation war room rented for the day. They’re walking into your actual place in the community. Protect it.
Jordan Maurer is the founder of Maurer Law in Auburn, California. He represents individuals and families in personal injury and elder abuse cases throughout Northern California, primarily in the Gold Country and Lake Tahoe regions. His practice focuses on TBI and spine injury cases. After building his trial skills at leading plaintiff and defense firms in larger cities, Jordan returned home to serve the rural communities that shaped him.
