2026 September

“You’re in Placer County.”

“You’re in Nevada County.”

“There aren’t million-dollar verdicts up there.”

“Those jurors are conservative.”

“I tried a case there 20 years ago and got a complete defense verdict.”

Anyone who regularly litigates personal-injury cases outside California’s larger metropolitan areas has heard some version of these statements during mediation or a mandatory settlement conference. The comments usually aren’t supported by verdict data. Instead, they’re based on reputation or a decades-old trial that has somehow become part of the county’s folklore.

I’ve noticed something else about these arguments – they rarely come at the beginning of the mediation. More often, they appear after the defense has become less comfortable negotiating liability or damages. When the conversation shifts away from the evidence and toward generalized statements about the venue, it’s often a sign that the defense would rather discuss the county than the case.

The challenge, of course, is that rural counties often do not provide much objective data to counter those arguments. There are plenty of reported verdicts out of Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, and the Bay Area, so lawyers can usually point to comparable verdicts to help frame a reasonable settlement value. In many rural counties, however, there may be only a handful of personal injury verdicts, or none that resemble your case. Sometimes the only verdict anyone remembers is a complete defense.

Without reliable verdict data, the defense has an easier time anchoring negotiations around assumptions about conservative jurors rather than the facts of your case.

Creating your own data

I wrote last month about focus groups, and this is exactly one of the reasons I’ve started conducting them regularly before significant mediations or settlement conferences.

I’m not looking for six-to-eight strangers to predict what a jury will do. They can’t. A group that spends a few hours with a case is not a substitute for a jury who spends days or weeks hearing live testimony, hopefully connecting with the client, and then deliberating together.

Instead, I’m looking to the focus groups for information I can use in preparing for trial and settlement discussions. I want to know which facts resonate, which facts create skepticism, what the “I just can’t get over” facts are, which defense themes work, which case frames work, and what damages numbers make people uncomfortable.

I recently had a three-level cervical disc replacement case where I asked for $3 million in non-economic damages, framing it as “$1 million per disc.” The local focus group participants, even the ones who liked my case, hated that approach. It completely backfired on me. Twice. I tried it again at mediation anyway when the mediator pressed me to explain how I was valuing non-economic damages so high. She hated it too. Lesson learned. I should’ve trusted my own data.

That’s the kind of information I want before mediation. And just as importantly, I want to know whether the defense’s valuation of the case sounds reasonable to ordinary people.

To test that, I often present the defense’s case as strongly as I can. I argue their liability themes. I emphasize weaknesses in my own case. I present the damages numbers I expect the defense to advocate during mediation and invite the group to tell me whether those numbers seem fair. If we haven’t completed expert depositions yet, I’ll often draw from opinions and numbers I’ve seen defense experts use in similar cases.

Sometimes the group agrees with the defense. That’s useful information. It helps me prepare my client for what they’re going to hear during mediation and gives them an opportunity to process some of those emotions beforehand, rather than for the first time while a mediator is applying pressure.

Other times, the focus group finds the defense’s arguments and numbers offensive. The participants explain why the defense’s position feels disconnected from the evidence or why the proposed damages fail to account for what the plaintiff experienced. Just as importantly, they identify the facts that matter most to them, including facts I may have underestimated or overlooked entirely.

So, when the defense starts hammering venue, I can bring the discussion back to those facts. And sometimes I can tell them directly that we’ve focus-grouped the case with real people from this community. We’ve heard what bothered them and what didn’t. We’re comfortable with where we are.

No focus group can tell you the value of your case. But it can tell you whether the defense’s negotiation themes are likely to resonate with people who resemble the jury to whom you’ll eventually present the case.

Turning information into leverage

The value of that information becomes apparent during mediation. When someone says, “This is a conservative county,” I no longer have to respond with my own opinion.

Instead, I can explain that we’ve recently presented the case to people from a similar community. I can tell the mediator that they weren’t offended by the damages number we’re requesting. I can explain that they were more troubled by the defendant’s conduct than we expected. I can point out that the defense themes didn’t gain the traction everyone assumed they would.

The conversation changes. Instead of debating folklore about rural juries, we’re discussing how people from that community actually reacted to the evidence.

Often, a skilled mediator will then shift the conversation away from “the rural county” and toward the trial itself, and, more specifically, what evidence is likely to come in and what is likely to stay out.

Again, this is where local knowledge becomes leverage. In the counties where I mainly practice, only a handful of judges regularly preside over civil jury trials. We pay close attention to how those judges rule on motions and handle pretrial issues. We also maintain good relationships with other plaintiff lawyers in the area. Sure, we’re competing for cases. But we’re also regularly litigating against many of the same defense firms, carriers, and experts. We share motions, rulings, and information about how particular issues have recently been handled.

That knowledge matters at mediation. If the defense is relying on a piece of evidence or a type of expert that I know a particular judge recently excluded, I want to know that. If they’re assuming the court will handle a pretrial issue a certain way and I’ve seen the same judge rule differently, I want to know that too.

Being able to point to recent rulings or simply explain how a particular judge tends to handle certain pretrial issues communicates something important to the mediator, the defense lawyer, and the adjuster: We know this courthouse, we know the case, and we’re prepared to try it here.

That may not translate neatly into a specific dollar increase. But I’ve repeatedly seen it change the direction of a mediation. The conversation stops being about vague assumptions concerning the county and returns to what actually matters: the evidence, the risk, and the numbers.

Every county has a reputation

Every county develops a reputation. Some are deserved. Others are built on isolated verdicts, old war stories, and assumptions no one has bothered to question.

Go into mediation with better information. Focus-group the case. Know the judge and the courtroom clerk. Talk to lawyers who regularly practice in that courthouse. If you’re coming from out of town, call a busy local plaintiff lawyer and learn the landscape.

You may never find the perfect comparable verdict. That’s okay. Keep the negotiation focused where it belongs: on the facts, the evidence, and the risk – not the ZIP code.

Jordan Maurer is the founder of Maurer Law in Auburn, California. He represents individuals and families in personal injury and elder abuse cases throughout Northern California, primarily in the Gold Country and Lake Tahoe regions. His practice focuses on TBI and spine injury cases. After building his trial skills at leading plaintiff and defense firms in larger cities, Jordan returned home to serve the rural communities that shaped him.