John M. O’Brien of O’Brien & Zehnder Law Firm takes pride in his three decades as a PI attorney, playing a vital role in securing some measure of justice for his clients by placing liability where it belongs and winning a fair financial recovery.
After a long day of mediation, O’Brien recently talked with Plaintiff magazine about how the money doesn’t reduce a person’s suffering, but it’s a step in the right direction.
“It’s about helping people get through some of the most difficult and tragic times of their lives and trying to help them find a silver lining, if it’s possible,” he said. “We just really do our best to make sure that in the end, no matter what the outcome is, they feel like they’ve been heard and that they got the justice that they needed.”
O’Brien founded his Elk Grove-based personal injury firm in 1996. Alongside firm partner Grant Zehnder and attorney Joel M. Smith, O’Brien handles personal injury and wrongful death cases throughout California involving car crashes, construction site accidents, slip-and-fall incidents, dog bites, product liability, and nursing home abuse. The O’Brien & Zehnder Law Firm has secured total client settlements of more than $250 million to date.
O’Brien said he walks into a civil courtroom knowing that juries already have a “very jaundiced view” of the legal system. “Money” is a dirty word when it comes to awarding damages for pain, suffering, and emotional distress, he explained.
“Jurors sometimes have a hard time with the concept that our system of justice is all about money. That’s the only way we have to even the scales of what’s been taken from somebody,” he said. “This is the only way we have to measure someone’s loss and hold the responsible party accountable. Money is the only way we have to do that. We don’t have vigilante justice anymore. If a loved one’s life is taken, you don’t get to go out and take the life of the person who caused that (death). The only way we have to restore some accountability is money.”
The plaintiff law path
Originally from Colorado Springs, O’Brien studied political science and economics at the University of the Pacific. He earned his law degree from the University of Southern California Gould School of Law and was admitted to the California State Bar in 1990.
He was drawn to law “because I like arguing. I like debate. I like the concept of justice. I just always had a lot of respect for lawyers and people who can think quickly on their feet,” he said. “I was just naturally drawn to it as an honorable profession and a way that I could live my life.”
Before going into practice for himself, O’Brien spent six years doing defense work at the now-defunct San Francisco-based Brobeck, Phleger & Harrison.
“I learned very quickly that was really not the kind of law I wanted to practice. I did not enjoy representing the defense, the big companies, insurance,” he said. “I did not like the way you’re treated by your clients and vice versa. I just did not like the approach of trying to minimize what they had to pay out when I thought that they bore more responsibility. That didn’t sit right with me.”
For instance, in the early 1990s he represented manufacturers against people who claimed injuries from asbestos exposure. In many instances, he found himself sympathizing with victims seeking compensation.
Today, O’Brien’s personal injury cases run the gamut, though he particularly enjoys handling products liability claims.
“Products liability is really interesting because it’s the one area of law where you don’t have to prove fault. All you have to prove is that the product in question was defective,” he said. Under strict liability, the defendant is legally responsible for the harm caused by their product, regardless of intent.
Recent products liability cases include representing a 44-year-old high school custodian against the manufacturer of a retractable basketball hoop that fell on her. The custodian sustained a crush injury to her right leg, from which she developed complex regional pain syndrome requiring numerous medical procedures. O’Brien’s case, which alleged that the hoop was defective, resolved on the eve of the trial with a $4.375 million settlement.
O’Brien’s team also represented a 30-year-old man whose left hand was amputated while working on farm equipment. According to the lawsuit, the client was attempting to clear a fault code on a forager machine used for cutting corn when his hand was pulled in and severed. O’Brien sought damages from the manufacturer alleging defective design and lack of warnings, ultimately securing $2.7 million in damages for the client.
O’Brien said he enjoys learning about complex product design, but also the challenge of explaining a complicated topic to jurors in understandable terms. He said that often involves creating technologically advanced multimedia presentations to better capture jurors’ attention and imaginations.
“There’s almost no limit now to what we can do in terms of animation, giving people visual or verbal evidence,” he said. “People can take in the information in so many different ways that you can make it so interesting and captivating.”
For instance, O’Brien’s firm recently employed an outside company to create a realistic animation of a crosswalk where a preschool-aged pedestrian was struck and seriously injured by a car.
“They were able to go and completely re-create the scene down to the smallest detail and give us the point of view of the driver who was approaching a crosswalk where a little four-year-old was hit,” O’Brien said. “The whole case hinged on what the driver could see and when they could see it. The animation folks were able to actually give us the point of view as you approach at a certain speed. It was a really fascinating exercise.”
In that case, claims were pursued against several parties including the driver and public entities, resulting in a $16.6 million settlement.
On teamwork
Attorneys O’Brien, Zehnder, and Smith, along with their paralegals and support staff, work together on every case that comes into the Sacramento County firm, according to O’Brien.
“We don’t split them up,” he said. “We all work on all the cases, and we bring our separate skill sets and experience levels to every case. So, we tend to take cases that are more complicated, that all of us can sink our teeth into at various stages.
“I found that to be a really effective way to not only prepare the case for trial, but to make sure that we’re considering every aspect and every creative theory or argument that we can come up with.”
O’Brien has known Zehnder and his family for many years, as his wife went to school with Zehnder’s parents. Zehnder can even be seen in the O’Briens’ 1990 wedding video, just a young kid dancing in the background.
When O’Brien wanted to expand his firm, Zehnder was recommended to him as a now-grown, accomplished lawyer. Zehnder joined the firm in 2013 and became a partner in 2019.
“It just turned out we were very compatible in terms of our practice styles and approach to the law,” O’Brien said, noting that they each have their unique strengths. “It has been really rewarding from my standpoint to watch him mature as a lawyer and get better. Whatever hand I played in that, I couldn’t be more pleased.”
O’Brien also values the collegiality he gains from being a part of several professional organizations, most notably the American Board of Trial Advocates (ABOTA).
“It’s a nice way to interact with other people that feel the same way you do about the legal profession and have a certain skill set, so I do enjoy that,” he said.
The lawyer life
Beyond work, O’Brien enjoys golfing, diving, and traveling domestically and internationally, especially if he can pursue those hobbies with his family. He has three adult children and five grandchildren, all of whom live nearby.
None of his family followed him into the legal field, despite his affinity for the profession.
“If it remains fun, I don’t know when or if I’ll retire because I enjoy what I do,” he said. “I really try and impress upon young people that it’s not all glamour; it’s a long road, it’s hard work, it’s a lot of years of learning the profession, learning your craft, getting better at what you do. You’re not always going to be highly compensated for it. There are a lot of areas of law where lawyers have a hard time scratching out a living, so you better really enjoy what you do, and you better have a passion for it.”
O’Brien said he’s at a stage in his career when he can take on good cases that he hopes to eventually take to trial.
“But as you know, settlements usually happen on the courthouse steps after we’ve really done an unbelievable job in preparation,” he said.
O’Brien said he’s sometimes presented with settlement offers that are too reasonable to refuse. That’s when he needs to put the decision in clients’ hands.
“I know that I could do better (in trial) for the clients than what’s on the table, but you can’t provide them a guarantee and you’re talking about a life-changing amount of money either way,” he said. “It’s all about them, not about you. You have to set aside your own desire to put a notch in your trial belt and lay it out for them exactly how you think it will play out in front of a jury and what you think is likely to happen.”
Jennifer McEntee is a freelance writer based in San Diego.
