2026 September

For nearly a decade, Uber and Lyft ran on a simple promise: Push a button, get a ride, trust the platform. This September, that promise faces its biggest legal test yet. For plaintiff counsel, these aren’t just news events, they’re a preview of how California juries and judges will treat the theories and discovery fights your own cases turn on.

Uber has been through three trials. The first ended in a defense verdict. 

The second, a nearly four-week federal trial in Phoenix brought by Oklahoma plaintiff Jaylynn Dean, produced an $8.5 million award after jurors found Uber’s apparent agency relationship with the driver was a substantial factor in the assault. The closing arguments there are worth studying for their own sake: Plaintiff’s counsel argued Uber marketed itself as safe for women traveling alone at night while its own risk-flagging data on the ride went unheeded, while Uber’s defense urged jurors to focus narrowly on “this driver, this rider and this trip” rather than company-wide statistics, stressing the driver had no criminal history and a near-perfect rider rating. 

That framing fight, foreseeability at the individual level versus foreseeability at the platform level, is likely to recur in every bellwether that follows, including September’s. A third trial ended with a $5,000 award, still a plaintiff win on liability. Two more Uber bellwethers are set for September: California state court (jury selection Sept. 14, 2026) and federal court in Texas (Sept. 30).

Lyft has never faced a jury on these claims. That changes this September, with its first sexual assault trial in California state court.

Uber’s safety reports document roughly 12,500 sexual assault incidents between 2017 and 2022. Lyft’s first report disclosed over 4,000 for 2017–2019, with several thousand more since. These company-published numbers double as an admission of notice, useful for pleading before discovery even starts.

Nearly 2,000 Lyft cases are pending in California’s coordinated proceeding, plus a growing federal MDL. Uber’s docket is larger: over 3,500 cases combined across its MDL and state court proceedings.

Three theories and the instructions behind them

Plaintiffs are generally pleading some mix of three theories, worth separating, along with the CACI instructions that frame them for a California jury. 

Firstly, vicarious liability / agency, governed by CACI 3700–3705. The Phoenix verdict turned on CACI 3701’s “tort liability asserted against principal” framework, with CACI 3705 governing whether an agency relationship existed at all. This is the fight both companies resist hardest. Their entire independent-contractor model depends on losing this instruction. Notably, CACI 3704’s directions for use briefly incorporated Proposition 22’s employee-status test before the Judicial Council removed that language in late 2025 following plaintiffs’-bar objections, restoring the traditional Borello right-to-control test. Counsel should confirm which version of 3704 a given court is using.

Next, common carrier duty, CACI 902 and 908. CACI 902 imposes an “utmost care” standard, higher than ordinary negligence, rooted in Civil Code section 2100 and Acosta v. Southern California Rapid Transit Dist. (1970) 2 Cal.3d 19. CACI 908 speaks directly to a carrier’s duty to protect passengers from assault. Getting a common carrier instruction, rather than an ordinary negligence one, meaningfully raises the bar the defense has to clear.

Negligent hiring, retention, and supervision are the workhorse claims: The company knew or should have known about a specific driver’s risk, without needing an agency or common-carrier finding at all. Plaintiffs’ lawyers should pick a lead theory early, since it determines which of these instructions you’re building your discovery and expert testimony toward, and locking in the agency or common carrier instruction is worth prioritizing over the negligence claim alone; it’s what raises the bar the defense has to clear.

Parallel proceedings, parallel pressure

Both companies face claims in California state court and federal MDL simultaneously, both centered in the Bay Area. State bellwethers move faster and read juries early; the MDL is built for scale. A verdict in one forum doesn’t bind the other, but it moves settlement posture in both. Forum choice at filing isn’t just procedural, weigh which bellwether pool and judge better fit your theory before deciding where to file.

What discovery should target

Internal safety reports, background-check protocols, and prior-incident data are central to the coming trials. For your own case, push for: incident-tracking databases and escalation records; background-check vendor details and re-check frequency; internal communications on safety features considered but not adopted; and complaint histories for drivers who worked both platforms. Courts have already ordered production on that last category, since overlapping driver pools undercut the “isolated incident” defense.

Expect fights over protective orders and sealing. Both companies treat incident data as trade-secret-adjacent; be ready to argue public interest outweighs confidentiality, especially where it overlaps with the companies’ own voluntary disclosures.

Punitive damages remain unclaimed by any plaintiff so far, despite the Phoenix agency finding. Under Civil Code section 3294, that requires clear and convincing evidence of malice, oppression, or fraud, in practice, conscious disregard of a known safety risk. A strong record generally needs a specific decision point, a shelved feature, an overridden safety recommendation, not just general awareness. The “knew vs. chose” distinction is exactly what plaintiff’s counsel leaned on in Phoenix, pointing to internal risk-flagging data the company had but didn’t act on, and that’s the kind of decision point counsel should be looking for in discovery now, not after a verdict makes punitive damages look viable.

The arbitration wall came down years ago

Mandatory arbitration once kept these claims out of public courtrooms. In 2018, a group of women publicly challenged Uber’s clause as unconscionable for violent-crime claims; Uber dropped mandatory arbitration for these claims, and Lyft matched within days. That’s what made today’s consolidated proceedings possible. Don’t assume this is universal, though: older claims and smaller competitors that never adopted the carve-out may still face enforceable arbitration clauses. Confirm the applicable terms of service at intake. 

What September means for valuation

September’s verdicts will function as a pricing signal for the entire docket. A defense-leaning result (something closer to $5,000) will likely compress early settlement offers. A second plaintiff win with real damages, especially punitive, gives mediators a stronger anchor. 

It’s also worth noting that Uber isn’t just fighting the big number. It filed a formal notice of appeal in May challenging the $5,000 Mensing verdict, arguing the common carrier instruction misapplied North Carolina law, and the company has publicly committed to appealing the $8.5 million Dean verdict over the apparent agency instructions. That a company facing thousands of similar claims would spend appellate resources on a five-figure judgment says something: this was never really about the damages in any one case. It’s about keeping the agency and common carrier instructions from hardening into settled law. If both verdicts are affirmed, that calculus flips. An appellate court blessing these instructions would strip Uber of its strongest remaining argument in every other pending case, and that’s likely to accelerate settlement talks across the docket far more than a single trial win or loss would. 

Build trial-ready files now rather than waiting on the outcome. The September verdicts should sharpen settlement planning, not substitute for it, a good result compresses the window to act, it doesn’t create one.

What accountability should look like

Advocates are pushing for continuous background-check monitoring, standardized incident reporting, and stronger ID verification. These aren’t just policy talk: Legislative testimony calling for reform can support a notice argument, and evolving industry safety standards can support an evolving standard-of-care claim. Whatever September’s juries decide, the volume of pending claims guarantees this fight continues well past this fall.

Samer Habbas is the founding and managing partner of Habbas & Associates. A UC Irvine graduate and Whittier Law School cum laude alumnus, Samer began his career inside a personal-injury firm while still in college – gaining early, firsthand exposure to how insurance companies undervalue claims and leave victims behind. He is a member of the Multi-Million Dollar Advocates Forum and the Consumer Attorneys Association of Los Angeles, and has been recognized by Best Lawyers in America, Super Lawyers Rising Stars, and Top 100 Trial Lawyers. For more information visit https://www.habbaspilaw.com/